Every Child Matters: Individualising Belonging and Removing Barriers to Inclusion

Belonging Effect Favicon

Written by Belonging Effect

Belonging Effect is committed to shaping intention into impact and supporting people with their Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, & Belonging strategy and training needs.

Belonging in Practice | Part 5 of 7

Equality gives everyone the same opportunities. Equity recognises that individuals may need different support to access those opportunities. Belonging requires us to understand the difference.

Over the past four weeks, we have been exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s (DfE) recently published School Belonging Case Studies Research. We have considered the importance of relationships, trust and psychological safety, celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination, and cultivating a strong school identity without compromising individuality.

This week, we turn our attention to another important area of practice identified in the research: individualised approaches to belonging. The research highlights how schools use their knowledge of individual pupils, alongside data, observation and relationships, to understand their strengths, identify barriers and provide tailored support.

This is an important reminder that while belonging is cultivated collectively, it is experienced individually. Two pupils can attend the same school, sit in the same classroom, experience the same teaching and follow the same expectations, yet have very different experiences of belonging.Treating everyone the same does not necessarily mean treating everyone fairly.

So how do we create school cultures where every child is recognised, understood, supported and empowered to flourish?

Knowing the Child Behind the Data

One of the five dimensions of belonging identified in the DfE research is individual recognition – this involves genuinely knowing pupils as individuals, recognising their strengths, understanding their needs and ensuring they feel safe to be themselves – schools hold significant amounts of information about their pupils.

We monitor attendance, attainment, behaviour, progress, additional needs, safeguarding concerns and a range of other indicators. These data provide valuable insights and can help us identify patterns, allocate resources and intervene when pupils require additional support, but data only tells part of the story:

  • An attendance percentage does not necessarily explain why a pupil is struggling to attend school.
  • A behaviour record does not reveal the full context of a child’s response to a particular situation.
  • An attainment grade does not capture their creativity, resilience, curiosity or potential.
  • A SEND diagnosis does not define the entirety of a child’s identity or experience.

We need to combine quantitative information with qualitative understanding. This requires relationships, observation, curiosity and meaningful conversations with pupils and their families. It also requires us to question our assumptions:

Do we know our pupils, or do we know the labels, categories and data associated with them?

Understanding the child behind the data enables us to move from responding to presenting difficulties towards recognising underlying needs, strengths and experiences.

Equality, Equity and the Difference Between Fairness and Sameness

Schools frequently describe their commitment to treating all pupils fairly, but fairness does not always mean providing everyone with exactly the same opportunities, resources or support.

Consider two pupils who are expected to participate in the same learning activity:

  • One may require additional processing time.
  • Another may need a quieter environment, an adapted resource or an alternative way to demonstrate their understanding.

Providing identical conditions does not necessarily create equitable opportunities to succeed.

Equity requires us to recognise that pupils begin from different starting points and may encounter different barriers. This does not mean lowering expectations – it means considering what support is necessary to enable pupils to meet ambitious expectations.

The DfE research reinforces the importance of maintaining high expectations alongside individualised support. This is particularly important because our assumptions about pupils’ capabilities can influence the opportunities we offer them. If we consistently underestimate a child’s potential because of their background, identity, disability or circumstances, we risk creating the very barriers we claim to be removing. Equally, if we insist that every child must demonstrate their capabilities in exactly the same way, we may inadvertently privilege some learners while disadvantaging others.

Equity is not about expecting less. It is about understanding what is needed to enable everyone to achieve more.

Inclusion Is About the Whole Child

Individualised approaches are often discussed primarily in relation to Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND). This is understandable as identifying needs, making reasonable adjustments and providing appropriate support are essential responsibilities for schools. However, individualising belonging requires us to consider more than SEND.

A child’s experience of school may also be shaped by their race, ethnicity, religion, gender, socioeconomic circumstances, family structure, language, disability, neurodivergence or experiences beyond the school gates. These identities and experiences may intersect in ways that create additional barriers or influence how support is accessed and experienced.

For example:

  • A neurodivergent pupil may experience sensory barriers that affect their ability to participate in particular school environments.
  • A pupil experiencing financial hardship may be unable to access enrichment opportunities that strengthen friendships and connection.
  • A child who is learning English as an additional language may need support to participate confidently while having considerable knowledge and skills in other languages.
  • A pupil experiencing racism or other forms of discrimination may feel unsafe or disconnected, despite receiving appropriate academic support.
  • A young carer may experience pressures outside school that affect their attendance, wellbeing and engagement.

These examples remind us that inclusion cannot be understood through one characteristic or category alone. Nor should we assume that pupils who share a particular identity will necessarily have the same experiences or needs.

Children do not arrive at school as a collection of separate characteristics. They arrive as whole people. So our approaches to inclusion must reflect this complexity.

Removing Barriers Rather Than Fixing Children

One of the most important questions we can ask when considering individualised approaches is where we locate the problem. When a pupil struggles to participate, engage or succeed, do we automatically assume that something needs to change about the child? Or do we also examine the environment, expectations, relationships and systems around them? 

This distinction is fundamental:

  • A pupil who struggles to concentrate in a noisy classroom may benefit from individual support, but we should also consider whether the learning environment can be adapted.
  • A child who repeatedly receives behaviour sanctions may need targeted intervention. But we should also examine whether expectations are clear, responses are equitable and underlying needs are understood.
  • A pupil who does not participate in extracurricular activities may appear disengaged. But we should explore whether financial, cultural, accessibility or social barriers are limiting their opportunities.

Individualised support is important, but it should not become a substitute for addressing systemic barriers. Otherwise, we risk asking children to adapt to environments that were not designed with their needs or experiences in mind.

Sometimes the most inclusive intervention is not changing the child. It is changing the conditions around them. This requires us to move beyond a deficit-based understanding of difference. Rather than asking only what a pupil cannot do, we should consider what they can do, what strengths they bring and what changes would enable them to participate more fully.

High Expectations, Appropriate Support and Pupil Agency

The DfE research highlights the reciprocal relationship between belonging, attendance and attainment. Leaders, staff and pupils described how feeling connected to school can encourage attendance and engagement, while positive learning experiences can strengthen belonging.

Importantly, the research also recognises that maintaining high expectations can communicate care and belief in pupils’ capabilities. However, high expectations must be accompanied by appropriate support.

We cannot simply tell pupils that we believe in them while failing to address the barriers that prevent them from succeeding. Nor should individualised approaches become something that is done to pupils without their involvement.

Pupil voice and agency are essential:

  • Do pupils understand the support being offered?
  • Have they been involved in identifying what works for them?
  • Are they able to express when an adjustment is unhelpful or makes them feel different from their peers?
  • Do they have opportunities to recognise their strengths, articulate their needs and influence decisions about their learning?

For some pupils, this may involve structured conversations or written feedback. For others, it may require visual communication, observation, trusted adults or alternative methods of participation. The important principle is that pupils should be active participants in shaping their experiences wherever possible – individualising belonging should strengthen agency, not create dependency.

The Importance of Families and Professional Collaboration

Understanding individual pupils requires us to recognise the expertise of those who know them well – families can provide invaluable insights into children’s strengths, interests, communication preferences, cultural identities and experiences beyond school.

Teachers, teaching assistants, pastoral staff, SENDCos and other professionals may also hold different pieces of the picture. However, these perspectives are not always brought together effectively:

  • Information may remain within individual teams.
  • Families may find themselves repeatedly explaining their child’s needs.
  • Pupils may experience inconsistent approaches across classrooms or transitions.
  • And well-intentioned interventions may become fragmented rather than coordinated.

A genuinely individualised approach requires collaboration and a joined up approach:

  • It involves listening to families without making assumptions about their circumstances or capabilities.
  • It involves sharing relevant information appropriately and ensuring that support is understood across the school.
  • It also involves reviewing whether interventions are having the intended impact.

Importantly, families should not have to become persistent advocates simply to secure support that their children need. Partnership should be built on mutual respect, shared understanding and collective responsibility.

From Individual Support to Inclusive Systems

There is an important balance to strike between responding to individual needs and creating environments that are inclusive by design. Schools cannot anticipate every circumstance or remove every barrier through universal approaches alone – individualised support will always be necessary, but we should also consider what repeated patterns tell us about our systems:

  • If several pupils struggle with the same transition, perhaps the transition process needs reviewing.
  • If particular groups are disproportionately represented in behaviour sanctions or exclusions, perhaps we need to interrogate our policies and practices.
  • If pupils with additional needs consistently miss enrichment opportunities, perhaps accessibility needs to be considered at the planning stage.
  • If families from particular communities rarely participate in school events, perhaps we need to reconsider how, when and where we engage with them.

Data can help us identify these patterns, but meaningful change requires us to understand the experiences behind them. This is where individualised approaches connect with whole-school leadership and accountability – we need to move beyond asking whether support is available and consider whether our systems are enabling everyone to participate, contribute and flourish. 

An inclusive school does not simply become better at supporting pupils who encounter barriers. It becomes more intentional about preventing unnecessary barriers from arising.

Things to Consider This Week

As we reflect on how individual pupils experience belonging within our school communities, we invite you to consider three questions.

  1. How well do we know our pupils?

Beyond attendance, attainment and behaviour data, what do we understand about their identities, strengths, experiences, aspirations and barriers to belonging? Whose stories might we not yet have heard?

  1. Where are the barriers?

When pupils struggle to participate, engage or succeed, do we focus primarily on changing their behaviour or providing individual interventions? How often do we examine the environments, expectations and systems that may be contributing to their experiences?

  1. What could we change this week?

What is one intentional action we could take to remove a barrier, strengthen pupil agency or create a more equitable experience of belonging?

Perhaps:

  • it is having a conversation with a pupil whose needs or experiences we do not fully understand;
  • it is reviewing an intervention with the pupil and their family;
  • it is examining participation data to identify who may be missing out;
  • it is adapting a classroom routine or learning environment;
  • it is questioning an assumption about what a particular pupil can achieve.

Small, intentional changes can make a significant difference to individual experiences, but we must also be willing to examine the wider systems that shape those experiences.

Final Reflections

Every child deserves to be recognised, respected and valued as an individual, but individualising belonging is not simply about creating different interventions for different pupils:

  • It is about understanding the whole child, recognising their strengths, listening to their experiences and removing the barriers that prevent them from participating fully.
  • It requires us to maintain high expectations while providing equitable opportunities to succeed.
  • It requires us to balance individual support with collective responsibility.
  • And it requires us to examine whether our school cultures, systems and expectations are genuinely inclusive or whether some pupils are continually expected to adapt to environments that do not meet their needs.

The DfE research reminds us that belonging is cultivated through intentional, contextual and sustained practice. There is no universal blueprint, but there is a shared responsibility to understand how our school communities are experienced and to respond to what we discover.

Because every child matters, every experience matters and belonging should never depend on a child’s ability to overcome barriers that we have the power to remove.

Continue the Conversation

This is Part 5 of The Belonging Effect’s seven-week series, Belonging in Practice, exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s School Belonging Case Studies Research.

Next Monday, we will explore Belonging Beyond the School Gates, considering how relationships with families, communities and wider partnerships can strengthen belonging and create opportunities for children and young people to flourish.

At The Belonging Effect, we support schools and organisations to move beyond good intentions and create cultures where belonging can be experienced, strengthened and measured.

Shaping Intention into Impact.

References and Further Reading

Department for Education (2026). School Belonging Case Studies Research. Research conducted by Ipsos in partnership with TONIC, Professor Kathryn Riley and the Anna Freud Centre.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/school-belonging-case-studies-research

The Belonging Effect: www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk


Cultivating a Strong School Identity: Creating Community Without Compromising Individuality

Belonging Effect Favicon

Written by Belonging Effect

Belonging Effect is committed to shaping intention into impact and supporting people with their Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, & Belonging strategy and training needs.

Belonging in Practice | Part 4 of 7

Strong school communities are built through shared values, collective identity and a sense of purpose. But genuine belonging requires us to celebrate individuality, not expect conformity.

Over the past three weeks, we have been exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s (DfE) recently published School Belonging Case Studies Research. We began by considering the importance of belonging as a whole-school culture, before examining relationships, trust and psychological safety, followed by the importance of celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination.

This week, we turn our attention to another area of practice identified in the research: cultivating a strong school identity. The research highlights how a unifying school ethos, shared values and smaller communities, such as house systems, can strengthen pupils’ sense of connection and collective identity. But this raises an important question: How do we create a strong sense of ‘we’ without losing sight of the individual ‘me’?

The Power of Collective Identity

One of the five dimensions of belonging identified in the DfE research is collective identity. Across the 16 case study schools, leaders, staff and pupils described the importance of feeling connected to something bigger than themselves. In primary schools, this was often articulated through the language of family, while secondary schools frequently emphasised community, shared identity and the role of house systems. These connections can provide pupils with a sense of security, pride and purpose. They communicate that we are part of a community where we matter, where our contributions are valued and where we share responsibility for one another.

For many pupils, school is one of the first places where they experience being part of a community beyond their immediate family. It provides opportunities to develop friendships, navigate differences, contribute to collective goals and understand their responsibilities towards others. However, a strong collective identity should not require individuals to suppress their differences. Belonging is not about becoming the same. It is about being connected while remaining ourselves. This distinction is fundamental to creating inclusive school cultures.

School Values: What We Say Versus What We Do

Most schools have a clearly articulated vision, mission and set of values. They are often displayed prominently on websites, walls, newsletters and prospectuses. We see words such as respect, kindness, integrity, courage, compassion and excellence. But how consistently are these values experienced?

A school may champion respect while some pupils experience discriminatory language…

It may promote kindness while staff feel unable to challenge decisions…

It may celebrate individuality while expecting everyone to conform to a narrow definition of acceptable behaviour…

It may articulate high expectations while failing to recognise the different barriers pupils encounter…

This is where we need to distinguish between espoused values and enacted values or as Mary Myatt says, values lived or values laminated. Espoused values describe what an organisation says it believes. Whereas, enacted values are demonstrated through its decisions, behaviours, relationships and everyday practices. The gap between the two can significantly influence how people experience belonging.

If we want our school values to be meaningful, we need to consider:

  • How are our values modelled by leaders and staff?
  • How are they reflected in our policies, curriculum and behaviour expectations?
  • How do they influence the way we respond to mistakes, conflict and challenge?
  • Are they experienced consistently by pupils, staff and families?
  • What happens when someone’s experience contradicts our stated values?

School culture is not defined by the values displayed on our walls. It is revealed through the behaviours experienced within them.

Creating Communities Within Communities

The DfE research highlights the value of smaller communities within larger schools, particularly through house systems. This is an important consideration as in large school communities, pupils can sometimes feel anonymous, disconnected or overlooked. Whereas smaller communities can provide opportunities for pupils to develop stronger relationships, experience recognition and contribute to a shared identity. 

House systems, tutor groups, mentoring programmes, clubs, enrichment activities and pupil leadership opportunities can all provide additional pathways to belonging. However, their effectiveness depends on how they are experienced. A house system may create pride and healthy competition, but does every pupil feel included?

  • A sports team may strengthen connection for those who participate, but what opportunities exist for pupils whose interests lie elsewhere?
  • A pupil leadership group may develop confidence and agency, but are the same confident and articulate pupils repeatedly selected?
  • A school may offer an impressive range of extracurricular activities, but are these equally accessible to pupils facing financial, social, cultural or additional needs-related barriers?

The question is not simply whether opportunities exist – it is whether everyone has a meaningful opportunity to participate.

Creating communities within communities only strengthens belonging when those communities are accessible, inclusive and valued. We should also recognise that pupils may experience belonging through different connections. For some, it may be their tutor group – for others, it may be a friendship group, a music ensemble, a lunchtime club or a trusted adult. There is no single pathway to belonging. The challenge is to create multiple opportunities for pupils to find connection, recognition and purpose.

Collective Identity Without Conformity

Strong school cultures often have established traditions, expectations and ways of doing things. Rituals and routines that can provide continuity, stability and a shared sense of identity. However, we must also be willing to examine whose identities and experiences have shaped those traditions:

  • Who decided what our school community should look, sound and behave like?
  • Whose values and perspectives are reflected?
  • Who finds it easy to participate?
  • And who may feel that belonging requires them to adapt, hide or compromise aspects of themselves?

This is particularly important when considering cultural, religious, racial, gender, socioeconomic and neurodivergent identities. For example, expectations around uniform, hairstyles, communication styles, participation or school traditions may be experienced differently across our communities. This does not mean that schools should abandon shared expectations. Rather, it means that we need to distinguish between expectations that promote safety, respect and collective responsibility, and those that may inadvertently reinforce conformity or exclusion.

A strong school identity should be sufficiently clear to create shared purpose, but sufficiently inclusive to accommodate differences – unity does not require uniformity. Indeed, the strength of a community can be measured by its ability to embrace different perspectives, experiences and identities while maintaining a shared commitment to its values.

Pupil Voice and Co-Creating School Culture

Another important theme within the DfE research is pupil voice and agency. This is particularly relevant when considering collective identity as if we want pupils to feel ownership of their school community, they need meaningful opportunities to influence it. 

Too often, school identity is something that is created by adults and communicated to pupils. We establish the vision, define the values, develop the expectations and then encourage pupils to demonstrate them, but what might change if pupils were genuinely involved in shaping their school culture?

  • What would they identify as the most important characteristics of a community where everyone belongs?
  • How might they define respect, inclusion, fairness or kindness?
  • What traditions would they want to retain, reconsider or introduce?
  • How might they create opportunities for pupils who currently feel disconnected?

Pupil councils, student leadership teams and consultation activities can provide valuable opportunities for participation. However, genuine agency requires more than being asked for an opinion – it requires pupils to see how their contributions influence decisions and lead to meaningful change.

We must also consider whose voices are heard – if the same pupils are consistently selected to represent their peers, we risk reinforcing existing hierarchies rather than broadening participation. A school community becomes stronger when its members are not simply expected to belong, but are empowered to shape what belonging means.

Staff Identity and Collective Responsibility

Although the DfE research focuses primarily on pupil belonging, its findings also reinforce the importance of staff wellbeing and belonging. A strong school identity cannot be sustained if staff feel disconnected from the values, leadership or culture of the organisation – staff need to understand the collective purpose of their work while feeling that their individual expertise, perspectives and contributions are recognised. This is particularly important in schools and trusts where teams may have different professional identities, experiences and priorities.

Collective identity should encourage collaboration rather than competition. It should create opportunities for colleagues to share knowledge, challenge assumptions and take responsibility for outcomes beyond their immediate classrooms or departments. For school trusts, this raises an additional challenge: How do we cultivate a shared trust identity while respecting the distinct histories, communities and cultures of individual schools?

A strong collective culture should not erase local identity. Instead, it should provide a shared framework of values, expectations and accountability that enables each school to flourish within its own context. This requires leaders to model the behaviours they expect from others. It also requires a willingness to move beyond individual priorities towards collective responsibility. A shared identity becomes meaningful when people recognise that the success, challenges and experiences of others are also their concern.

School Identity Is Experienced, Not Imposed

One of the most important messages emerging from the DfE research is that there is no universal blueprint for belonging. Schools need to understand their context, communities and individual pupils. This principle is equally important when cultivating a strong school identity as what creates connection in one school may not have the same impact in another:

  • Traditions that are meaningful to one community may feel unfamiliar or exclusionary to another.
  • Structures that work well in a small primary school may require adaptation within a large secondary school.

We therefore need to approach school identity with curiosity rather than assumption. This means listening to pupils, staff and families. It means recognising that different groups may experience the same school culture differently. It means being willing to examine established practices, even when they are longstanding or well-intentioned. And it means understanding that school identity is not static.

As communities evolve, our cultures must be able to respond. The strongest school identities are not necessarily those with the longest traditions or the clearest slogans. They are those where people experience a genuine sense of connection, recognition and shared responsibility.

Things to Consider This Week

As we reflect on the identity and culture of our school communities, we invite you to consider three questions.

  1. What unites us?

What are the values, experiences and shared commitments that create a sense of collective identity within our school? How consistently are these experienced by pupils, staff and families?

  1. Who might feel disconnected?

Which pupils or staff may struggle to see themselves reflected in our school identity? Are there traditions, expectations or structures that inadvertently create barriers to participation or belonging?

  1. How can we strengthen collective ownership?

What is one intentional action we could take this week to enable pupils or staff to contribute more meaningfully to shaping our school culture?

Perhaps:

  • it is revisiting our school values with pupils and exploring what they mean in practice;
  • it is reviewing participation in clubs, house activities or leadership opportunities;
  • it is inviting feedback from pupils who may feel less connected to school;
  • it is creating opportunities for staff across different teams or schools to collaborate;
  • it is questioning a longstanding tradition to ensure it remains inclusive and relevant.

The important thing is to recognise that a strong school identity is not something we simply communicate – it is something we collectively create, experience and sustain.

Final Reflections

A strong school identity can provide pupils and staff with a powerful sense of connection, purpose and pride. It can also strengthen relationships, encourage participation and create a shared commitment to the success and wellbeing of the whole community, but collective identity must never come at the expense of individual identity. We need to create school cultures where shared values provide direction without demanding conformity and where traditions strengthen connection without excluding difference.

Continue the Conversation

This is Part 4 of The Belonging Effect’s seven-week series, Belonging in Practice, exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s School Belonging Case Studies Research.

Next Monday, we will explore Every Child Matters: Individualising Belonging, considering how schools can recognise individual strengths, understand different needs and remove barriers to participation and success.

At The Belonging Effect, we support schools and organisations to move beyond good intentions and create cultures where belonging can be experienced, strengthened and measured.

Shaping Intention into Impact.

References and Further Reading

Department for Education (2026). School Belonging Case Studies Research. Research conducted by Ipsos in partnership with TONIC, Professor Kathryn Riley and the Anna Freud Centre.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/school-belonging-case-studies-research

The Belonging Effect: www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk


The Quiet Gap in How Schools Build Belonging

Liz Robson-Kelly portrait

Written by Liz Robson-Kelly

Educator, Positive and Organisational Psychologist, leading expert on Positive Education in the UK.

When we talk about belonging in schools, we tend to reach for structural solutions – inclusive timetabling, PSHE curriculum, restorative practice. These all matter. But after fifteen years working in positive psychology and coaching with young people, I’ve become convinced we’re overlooking something important: the quality of the relational, one-to-one support we offer to the students who need more than a whole-class approach.

Student wellbeing coaching is one of the most credible, evidence-based ways we have of building belonging, resilience and early intervention capacity in schools. And for most school leaders, it’s simply not on the radar yet. I don’t think that’s their fault. It’s a structural blind spot in how the sector presents the evidence.

Why Coaching for Students Gets Missed

In schools, the word “coaching” almost always points to staff development, for example, instructional coaching, leadership coaching, CPD. When commissioning documents or guidance reference it, they mean staff-to-staff support. So even when a pastoral lead is actively looking for targeted, early-intervention wellbeing provision, student coaching simply doesn’t appear. It’s filed under the wrong heading.

There’s also an evidence pipeline problem. Coaching research in education has often used qualitative and practice-based designs that don’t travel easily into the evidence catalogues school leaders are used to consulting. Although the evidence exists and has been building for over two decades, it is harder to find and compare with more visibly branded programmes.

What Student Wellbeing Coaching Actually Does

Student wellbeing coaching is a structured, non-directive relationship between a trained practitioner and a young person. It isn’t therapy. It isn’t mentoring in the advice-giving sense. A coach asks questions, listens, and helps a student clarify their own goals and next steps, building self-awareness, autonomy and a sense of capability. That last part matters: autonomy, competence and relatedness are the three psychological needs that Self-Determination Theory identifies as central to motivation and wellbeing. They are also, on the model the DfE’s own commissioned research uses, the mechanism through which belonging operates.

A 2026 University of Cambridge study found that pupils who strongly disagree they belong at school score on average 7.72 Attainment 8 points lower than those who strongly agree, roughly a full GCSE grade across eight subjects. A meta-analysis by Allen et al. (2018) found that the strongest predictors of belonging are teacher support and a young person’s own positive personal characteristics: coping, self-efficacy, hope. Both of those predictors sit squarely within what a structured coaching relationship is designed to build.

How Student Wellbeing Coaching Fits the Current Framework

Student wellbeing coaching isn’t a novelty sitting outside the current policy landscape. It meets the criteria set out in the Anna Freud/DfE targeted support guidance: early and preventative, delivered by suitably trained staff, non-clinical and strengths-based, with evaluation planned in from the outset. The DfE’s Inclusion Bases in Schools guidance already names coaching as a legitimate mechanism for building inclusion capacity. Although currently framed around staff, it points towards exactly the right purpose.

With SEND reform placing greater responsibility on schools to deliver structured in-house targeted support through the “Targeted” layer in the new two-tier model, schools need practical, accredited, teachable frameworks their existing pastoral staff can use. Coaching is one of the clearest answers available.

What the Evidence Shows

Van Nieuwerburgh and Barr’s (2016) review of coaching in education identifies coaching for student success and wellbeing as a distinct and established strand. My own peer-reviewed grounded theory study (Robson-Kelly and van Nieuwerburgh, 2016) found meaningful gains in how young people at risk of mental health problems understood themselves and their circumstances. Passmore and Brown (2009) found that academic coaching improved both exam performance and hope. Our own pre- and post-intervention data at Worth-it, using the DASS-21 and SDQ with thirty young people aged 13 to 16, shows measurable wellbeing improvements after a structured coaching programme — the kind of evidence the DfE guidance explicitly asks schools to build in.

Where to Start

Schools can build this capacity internally, using staff who already hold trusted relationships with pupils. You don’t need to start big.

If you’d like a feel for the coaching approach, the Introduction to Coaching Young People CPD bundle is a free starting point. If you’re ready to train staff to deliver this within your setting, the Worth-it Coach Training course is accredited by the Association for Coaching and grounded in the research described here. And if you’re not yet sure where coaching fits in your wider wellbeing strategy, the Wellbeing and Inclusion Planning Tool will help you find clarity.

Belonging isn’t built through curriculum alone. It’s built through relationships – and coaching gives more adults in your school the skills to make those relationships count.

References

Allen, K., Kern, M.L., Vella-Brodrick, D., Hattie, J. and Waters, L., 2018. What schools need to know about fostering school belonging: a meta-analysis. Educational Psychology Review, 30(1), pp.1–34.

Banerjee, P., 2026. School belonging and attainment at key stage 4: linked data study. University of Cambridge / Department for Education.

Deci, E.L. and Ryan, R.M., 1985. Intrinsic motivation and self-determination in human behaviour. New York: Plenum Press.

Department for Education, 2026. Inclusion bases in schools guidance.

Department for Education and Anna Freud, 2026. Developing your school or college targeted mental wellbeing support.

Passmore, J. and Brown, A., 2009. Coaching non-adult students for enhanced examination performance: a longitudinal study. Coaching: An International Journal of Theory, Research and Practice, 2(1), pp.54–64.

Robson-Kelly, L. and van Nieuwerburgh, C., 2016. What does coaching have to offer to young people at risk of developing mental health problems? A grounded theory study. International Coaching Psychology Review, 11(1), pp.75–92.

van Nieuwerburgh, C. and Barr, M., 2016. Coaching in education. In: T. Bachkirova, G. Spence and D. Drake, eds. The SAGE handbook of coaching. London: Sage.

Worth-it Positive Education CIC, n.d. Internal pre- and post-intervention evaluation data using DASS-21 and SDQ.


The Stories We Choose To Tell

Shilpa Darbar portrait

Written by Shilpa Darbar

With over a decade of experience as Head of History, Shilpa’s experience extends beyond classroom instruction to strategic leadership in curriculum development. She has reshaped the History curriculum to promote diversity and inclusiveness, a mission echoed in her published work with Impact and on her Substack. Her expertise in public speaking aids in advocating for educational innovation and elevating varied perspectives.

Conscious Curriculum Choices 

One of my proudest achievements as a Head of Department has been the diversification of our KS3 curriculum. When I first inherited the curriculum, I realised that many of the stories I had been taught as a pupil were the same ones I was now teaching my own students. That prompted an uncomfortable question: were we preparing young people to understand the world as it is today, or simply reproducing the curriculum we had inherited? 

The selection of historical periods, places and perspectives within the History curriculum is crucial, not only for fostering students’ engagement and enjoyment of the subject, but also for shaping what Victoria Elliott describes as ‘disciplinary powerful knowledge’ (Elliott, 2021, p. 8). The texts, sources and voices we include shape the culture of our curriculum, elevating certain values and perspectives while marginalising others. In their study of students aged 12–14, Harris and Reynolds found that ‘although many students enjoy History, they fail to fully understand its value […] especially those from minority ethnic backgrounds, [who] feel a lack of personal connection to the past, as they do not see themselves in the History they are taught’ (Harris and Reynolds, 2014, p. 46). Similarly, Barton and Levstik argue that a sense of identification is fundamental to the purpose of studying History, suggesting that students need to connect with the past at a personal, familial or national level (Barton and Levstik, 2004).  

Yet, in my experience, History in many UK schools has traditionally prioritised a national narrative of progress and achievement through a predominantly white lens. This was certainly true of my own primary and secondary school education, and although considerable progress has been made in recent years to broaden the curriculum, our work as educators is far from complete. As Bennie Kara argues, if the curriculum is “limited to the thoughts, experiences, histories and achievements of white, western Europe”, it denies students the opportunity to “view the truth of the world they live in” (Kara, 2021, p. 41). Heeding this advice means designing a curriculum that enables pupils to see their own experiences reflected while also developing an understanding of the lives and perspectives of others. Without this balance, we risk alienating some students and overlooking the rich diversity of experiences represented within our classrooms. 

Why tokenism isn’t enough 

Of course, recognising the need for greater representation does not mean simply adding a lesson on a famous South Asian historical figure during South Asian Heritage Month in July, or including a woman at the end of a unit that otherwise remains unchanged. Diversity is not something that can be bolted onto an existing curriculum as an afterthought. 

Tokenistic approaches often fail because they leave the underlying historical narrative untouched. They ask students to view certain individuals as exceptional rather than questioning why some stories have traditionally been centred while others have been marginalised. If we are serious about broadening students’ understanding of the past, we need to move beyond asking, Who can we add? Instead, we should ask, Why has this story been told in this way? 

In our department, diversification rarely meant creating entirely new units. More often, it meant asking different questions of the topics we already taught. 

For example, when teaching the British Empire, we asked, whose experiences were privileged? When studying the Industrial Revolution, whose voices were absent? When examining the World Wars, were we presenting them solely as British stories, or as global conflicts involving millions across the Empire and beyond? 

Sometimes the changes were substantial; often they were surprisingly small. A new enquiry question. A different source. A case study that challenged assumptions. Collectively, however, these decisions transformed the curriculum into one that better reflected both historical scholarship and the diversity of our classrooms. 

Diversification is about accuracy 

One of the strongest arguments for diversification isn’t actually representation, it’s accuracy. Modern historical scholarship has transformed our understanding of the past. Historians now pay far greater attention to women’s History, migration, empire, global History, everyday life and previously overlooked voices. If school curricula ignore these developments, they risk becoming outdated rather than rigorous. 

Curriculum diversification is therefore not simply a moral or pastoral project; it is an academic one. As historical scholarship develops, our curricula should develop alongside it. We would never continue teaching outdated interpretations simply because they are familiar. The same principle should apply to whose stories we choose to tell. Two key texts that shaped my thinking around this were David Olusoga’s Black and British: A Forgotten History (2016), and Sathnam Sanghera’s Empireland: How Imperialism Has Shaped Modern Britain (2021). These works questioned existing narratives in a way that really resonated with me personally and professionally.  

Putting diversification into practice 

Rather than simply introducing new topics, one of the most significant changes we made was embedding a recurring feature called ‘Meanwhile Elsewhere’ into every unit of study. At key points throughout each topic, students pause to explore what was happening elsewhere in the world at the same time. While studying the Norman Conquest, for example, they also learn about the flourishing kingdom of Benin in West Africa. This simple addition helps students move beyond seeing History through a solely British or European lens. It reinforces the idea that societies have always developed simultaneously, often influencing one another in complex ways, and encourages pupils to view the past as interconnected rather than a collection of isolated national stories.  

One of the clearest examples of our changing approach can be seen in our study of the British Empire. We wanted students to understand that empire was never simply a story of expansion, administration and economic growth. Alongside examining the development of the Empire itself, we deliberately foreground stories of resistance, resilience and the struggle for self-determination. Our in-depth study of the Indian independence movement allows students to encounter a range of voices and methods of resistance, from constitutional reformers like Nehru, to mass civil disobedience in the Quit India Movement led by Gandhi, while considering the profound consequences of colonial rule in both the short and long-term. By studying independence movements alongside imperial expansion, students gain a more balanced understanding of empire as a contested process, experienced very differently depending on whose perspective is being considered.  

The First World War provides another opportunity to broaden historical perspectives. For many students, the conflict is synonymous with trenches, mud and the Western Front. While these experiences remain central, we deliberately widen the lens by examining other theatres of war, including campaigns in Gallipoli, East Africa and the Middle East. We also explore the enormous contribution made by soldiers from across the British Empire, paying particular attention to the experiences of Indian troops who fought in Europe, Africa and the Middle East. This helps students recognise that the First World War was exactly that, a global conflict involving millions of people from across the world. It also prompts valuable discussions about why some contributions have traditionally been celebrated while others have been overlooked. 

Perhaps the most transformative change has been the way we teach migration. Rather than introducing migration as a post-war story beginning with Windrush, we present it as a continuous thread running throughout British History. From Year 7 onwards, students encounter migration chronologically, exploring how and why different groups have arrived in Britain across centuries—from Romans, Anglo-Saxons and Vikings to Huguenots, Jewish communities, Irish migrants, Commonwealth citizens and more recent arrivals. This approach enables pupils to trace patterns of continuity and change, examine the diverse reasons people migrate, and appreciate the lasting contributions migrant communities have made to British society. By the time students reach the twentieth century, they recognise that migration is not an exception in Britain’s past but one of the defining features of British history.   

A conscious choice 

Curriculum design is ultimately an act of choice. Every lesson we include means another cannot. Every source we select elevates one perspective over another. The question then is not whether our curriculum tells a story because it always will. The real question is: whose story are we choosing to tell? 

If our aim is to prepare young people to understand both the past and the diverse society in which they live, then perhaps the challenge is not to tell more stories, but to tell richer, more complete ones. 

Signposting

If you would like to learn more about how I approached managing this change, please see my article in Impact, Multidirectional narratives: Diversifying the English and History curriculums, (Darbar and Greenfield, 2022) 
https://my.chartered.college/impact_article/multidirectional-narratives-diversifying-the-english-and-history-curriculums/  


From Bystanders to Upstanders: Challenging Language, Bias and Microaggressions in International Schools

Hannah Wilson portrait

Written by Hannah Wilson

Founder and Director of the Belonging Effect (formerly Diverse Educators).

Inclusive Leadership in Practice: Reflections from the Festival of Education Thailand 

In my previous blog, I reflected on my keynote and workshop at FOBISIA’s annual leadership conference in Bangkok, exploring the role of inclusive leadership in cultivating cultures of belonging. My central message was that inclusion cannot simply be something we believe in, talk about or aspire to achieve. It must be something we intentionally model, embed and experience through our everyday interactions, relationships and behaviours.

During my visit to Thailand, I also attended the Festival of Education hosted at Wellington College International Bangkok and l  facilitated two workshops exploring how educators can challenge derogatory language and microaggressions in their schools. 

Both workshops were designed to move the conversation from awareness to action, encouraging participants to reflect not only on the language and behaviours they encounter, but also on their own confidence and competence in challenging them, because inclusive leadership is not simply about what we say we value. It is about what we are prepared to challenge when those values are compromised. If we want to cultivate cultures of belonging, we must be prepared to challenge the behaviours that undermine them.

1. The Power of Language: Words Matter

Language is one of the most powerful tools we have as educators and leaders. It can build relationships, strengthen identities, communicate expectations and create connections, but language can also reinforce stereotypes, perpetuate prejudice, marginalise individuals and undermine their sense of belonging.

In our first workshop, Challenging Derogatory Language, we explored the language we hear and use in our schools, examining how everyday words and phrases can communicate messages of exclusion. Some language is deliberately discriminatory, other language may be used without an awareness of its historical context, negative associations or potential impact. The challenge is that familiarity can normalise language that should be questioned.

How often have we heard someone dismiss a discriminatory comment with:

  • “It was only a joke.”
  • “I didn’t mean anything by it.”
  • “You’re being too sensitive.”
  • “That’s just how we speak.”
  • “We’ve always called it that.”

These responses can minimise the experiences of those who have been harmed, while protecting the comfort of those responsible.

Intent does not negate impact – we may not always intend to cause harm, but we are still responsible for recognising the impact of our words and taking steps to repair relationships when harm occurs. 

As educators, we have a particular responsibility to model language that respects the dignity and identity of every individual. This does not mean that we will always get everything right. It means being willing to listen, reflect, learn and change.

2. Understanding Microaggressions: The Cumulative Impact of Everyday Interactions

Our second workshop, Challenging Microaggressions, moved the conversation from language to behaviours – microaggressions are everyday verbal, non-verbal or environmental slights, insults or invalidations that communicate negative messages about an individual’s identity or membership of a marginalised group. They can be intentional or unintentional, conscious or unconscious.

The term ‘micro’ can be misleading as it does not mean that the impact is insignificant. Indeed, the cumulative impact of repeated microaggressions can be profound, particularly when individuals experience them across multiple environments and relationships.

During the workshop, we explored three different types of microaggressions:

  • Microinsults: Often subtle or unconscious comments and behaviours that communicate rudeness, insensitivity or stereotypical assumptions. For example, expressing surprise at a Black professional’s qualifications or consistently referring to a female doctor by her first name while using professional titles for her male colleagues.
  • Microassaults: More deliberate and derogatory expressions or behaviours that communicate discriminatory attitudes towards individuals or groups. These may include intentional insults, exclusionary behaviour or the deliberate use of offensive language.
  • Microinvalidations: Comments or behaviours that dismiss, minimise or negate someone’s lived experiences. For example: “I’m sure they didn’t mean it…” “I meant it as a compliment…” “You shouldn’t be so sensitive…”

These responses can be particularly damaging because they invalidate the individual’s experience while shifting attention away from the behaviour being challenged.

One of the examples we explored was the seemingly innocent question: “Where are you really from?” While curiosity about someone’s background may be genuine, repeatedly questioning their origins can communicate that they are perceived as different, foreign or not fully belonging. The important question is not simply what was said, but what message was communicated and how it was experienced.

We need to consider that when people repeatedly experience messages that question their identity, legitimacy or belonging, what does this do to their confidence, wellbeing and sense of self-worth? And what happens when these experiences are dismissed by the very people who have a responsibility to protect and support them?

3. Beyond International Diversity: Whose Experiences Are We Overlooking?

One of the most powerful aspects of facilitating these workshops in Bangkok was hearing colleagues share their own lived experiences. Black and neurodivergent educators spoke openly about the bias they had navigated while working in international schools, sometimes encountering prejudice and assumptions from a range of stakeholders across their school communities. 

Their contributions reminded us that discrimination is not always overt, nor is it confined to particular relationships or professional contexts. It can manifest through everyday interactions, assumptions, expectations and behaviours that gradually undermine an individual’s confidence, professional identity and sense of belonging. I was particularly struck by the willingness of colleagues to share experiences that may not always be visible or acknowledged within their organisations.

We cannot assume that because we work in diverse, international communities, we have automatically created inclusive cultures. Diversity may be visible in the composition of our school communities, but belonging is experienced through the quality of our relationships, the behaviours we tolerate and the actions we take when someone’s dignity is compromised.

Another particularly thought-provoking conversation was with my student helper, who reflected on the lack of awareness among some international White staff about the identities and experiences of Black, Brown and biracial children from the host country. This raised an important question about the relationship between international education, cultural competence and belonging.

International schools often pride themselves on their diversity, global outlook and multicultural communities. However, having a diverse school population does not necessarily mean that we understand the identities, histories and lived experiences of the children and families within it. We must be willing to examine whose cultures are centred, whose experiences are understood and whose identities are overlooked.

How can we claim to be internationally minded if we are not sufficiently curious about, or responsive to, the identities and experiences of the communities in which our schools are situated?

For me, this conversation reinforced the importance of culturally responsive leadership and the need for international educators to develop an understanding of the local context, rather than assuming that their own cultural perspectives and experiences are universal. It also raised a wider question about whose knowledge and experiences are valued within international education:

  • Are we creating opportunities for local staff, students and families to shape our understanding of inclusion? 
  • Or are we interpreting their experiences through perspectives and assumptions that may not reflect their realities?

If the adults working within our schools do not consistently experience inclusion, psychological safety and belonging, what might this tell us about the cultures we are creating for our children?

Belonging requires more than representation – it requires recognition, understanding, respect and meaningful action.

4. From Consciousness to Confidence to Competence

Across both workshops, I used three interconnected principles to frame our learning: Consciousness, Confidence and Competence (our 3 C’s).

These are essential to developing our capacity to recognise, challenge and disrupt discriminatory language and behaviour.

Consciousness: What are we noticing?

Before we can challenge something, we must first recognise it. This requires us to develop greater awareness of our own assumptions, biases, language and behaviours, as well as those we encounter in others. We need to become more conscious of whose experiences are represented, whose voices are heard and whose identities are affirmed or undermined. It also requires us to recognise that our own experiences are not universal. What feels harmless to one person may be deeply uncomfortable or damaging to another.

Confidence: Are we prepared to challenge?

Awareness alone does not create change. We may recognise inappropriate language or behaviour but hesitate to intervene because we feel uncomfortable, fear conflict or worry about saying the wrong thing. Sometimes, we prioritise maintaining relationships over addressing behaviour that undermines others, but whose comfort are we protecting when we choose to remain silent?

Developing confidence means becoming more comfortable with discomfort, recognising that courageous conversations are an essential part of inclusive leadership. It also means understanding that we do not need to have all the answers before we intervene.

Competence: Do we know how to respond?

Knowing that something is inappropriate is different from knowing how to challenge it effectively. This is where professional learning, practical strategies and opportunities to rehearse conversations become essential – we need to equip educators with the language, skills and confidence to interrupt harmful behaviours, challenge assumptions and facilitate learning:

  • Consciousness helps us recognise the problem. 
  • Confidence enables us to challenge it. 
  • Competence allows us to respond effectively.

All three are necessary if we want to move from good intentions towards meaningful impact.

5. Calling In and Calling Out: The Importance of Courageous Conversations

One of the challenges educators face is knowing how to respond when they hear inappropriate language:

  • Should we challenge someone publicly or privately? 
  • Should we ask questions or make statements? 
  • How do we hold people accountable without creating unnecessary defensiveness?

In our workshop, we explored practical approaches to challenging language through curiosity, education and empathy. Sometimes, a question can create an opportunity for reflection: “I noticed you used that phrase. What does it mean to you?” or: “What was your intention in saying that?”

We can then encourage individuals to consider the impact of their language:

  • “How might someone else experience those words?”
  • “What assumptions might that language reinforce?”
  • “Can we think of a different way to express what you intended?”

These questions create opportunities for dialogue, reflection and re-education. However, there are also occasions when a more direct response is necessary. When language is overtly discriminatory, harmful or threatening, we have a responsibility to challenge it clearly and immediately.

Calling someone in can create opportunities for learning and reflection. Calling someone out can establish clear boundaries and communicate that discriminatory behaviour is unacceptable. Both approaches have their place. The important distinction is understanding when we are creating an opportunity for learning and when we need to intervene to prevent further harm.

Psychological safety should never be confused with avoiding accountability – creating safe, but brave, spaces requires us to balance compassion with challenge, ensuring that the dignity and wellbeing of those experiencing discrimination remain central to our response.

6. From Bystanders to Upstanders: The Responsibility to Act

A recurring theme across both workshops was the responsibility we all share to challenge discrimination. We often talk about the importance of allyship, but allyship is not simply a statement of support or an expression of good intentions. It requires action:

  • A bystander witnesses inappropriate language or behaviour but does not intervene.
  • An upstander recognises the potential harm and takes appropriate action to challenge, interrupt or report it.

This is not always easy as we may be uncertain about what we have heard, concerned about the consequences of intervening or reluctant to challenge someone in a position of authority. But silence can communicate acceptance, particularly when discriminatory language and behaviours become normalised within a school culture.

During the microaggressions workshop, we asked participants to identify examples of microaggressions and consider how allyship could have disrupted them. This shifted the focus from simply recognising harmful behaviour towards considering our collective responsibility to respond.

Practical intervention might include:

  • Challenging: Addressing inappropriate words or behaviours directly when it is safe to do so.
  • Questioning: Encouraging individuals to reflect on their assumptions and the impact of their language.
  • Supporting: Checking in with the individual who has experienced discrimination, listening to their perspective and respecting their wishes.
  • Recording: Recognising patterns of behaviour and documenting incidents where appropriate.
  • Escalating: Reporting concerns through relevant leadership, safeguarding or organisational procedures.

Importantly, we should not expect individuals from marginalised groups to carry the responsibility for educating others or challenging every incident they experience as this is a shared responsibility. Allyship is not defined by what we believe – it is demonstrated through what we do.

7. The Relationship Between Inclusion and Safeguarding

One of my reflections following the conference was the importance of making more explicit connections between inclusive leadership and safeguarding. We often discuss safeguarding in relation to policies, procedures, reporting responsibilities and the identification of risk. These are, of course, essential, however, safeguarding is also influenced by the everyday culture of a school:

  • Consider the child who repeatedly hears derogatory language about their identity.
  • The student whose experiences of racism are dismissed as harmless jokes.
  • The young person who witnesses discriminatory behaviour but does not feel confident that an adult will intervene.
  • Or the member of staff who experiences repeated microaggressions but fears that raising concerns will damage their professional relationships.

What messages are these individuals receiving about their safety, dignity and belonging? And how might these experiences influence their willingness to speak up when something more serious occurs?

A culture in which discriminatory language and behaviour are routinely minimised is unlikely to foster the trust and psychological safety that effective safeguarding depends upon. Every inappropriate comment does not constitute a safeguarding concern. However, patterns of discrimination, harassment and identity-based bullying can create risks to children’s wellbeing and safety that schools must take seriously.

Inclusive leadership and safeguarding should therefore be understood as interconnected responsibilities: both require us to notice what others may overlook, listen to experiences that challenge our assumptions and respond appropriately when harm occurs; both depend upon cultures where people trust that their concerns will be heard and acted upon and both require leaders to demonstrate that dignity, respect and safety are non-negotiable.

8. Moving Beyond Individual Awareness Towards Collective Accountability

While individual awareness and confidence are important, meaningful cultural change requires more than isolated interventions – schools need shared expectations, consistent responses and collective accountability:

  • If one teacher challenges discriminatory language while another dismisses it, what message are students receiving?
  • If leaders communicate a commitment to inclusion but fail to address repeated microaggressions among staff, what does this reveal about the organisation’s culture?
  • If individuals are encouraged to report concerns but see little evidence of action, why would they continue to speak up?

Inclusive leadership requires us to examine the relationship between our stated values and our everyday practices. This includes reviewing the language we use in policies and communications, the behaviours we challenge, the experiences we listen to and the accountability we establish. It also means recognising that mistakes will happen – we will sometimes use inappropriate language, make assumptions or unintentionally cause harm.

The measure of an inclusive culture is not whether mistakes ever occur, but how individuals and organisations respond when they do:.

  • Do we become defensive or curious?
  • Do we dismiss the impact or acknowledge it?
  • Do we protect our intentions or take responsibility for our actions?
  • Do we repeat the same behaviours or demonstrate that we have learned?

Accountability should not simply be about identifying what went wrong – it should be about taking responsibility for what happens next.

9. Five Reflective Questions for School Leaders

As we concluded our workshops, I encouraged participants to consider how they might translate their learning into their everyday professional practice.

For school leaders, I would suggest starting with five questions:

  • What language and behaviours have become normalised in our school culture that we may need to challenge?
  • How confident and competent are our staff in recognising and responding to derogatory language, bias and microaggressions?
  • Whose experiences of our school culture might be different from our own, and how are we listening to those perspectives?
  • How consistently do we challenge discriminatory behaviour, regardless of who is responsible or their position within the organisation?
  • How do we know that our commitment to inclusion is being experienced by the people we have a responsibility to support and safeguard?

These questions are not intended to generate comfortable answers – they are intended to create opportunities for honest reflection, courageous conversations and meaningful action.

Final Reflections: What Are We Prepared to Challenge?

My experience at the Festival of Education Thailand reinforced something I regularly return to in my work with schools and leaders – cultivating belonging requires more than celebrating diversity, communicating inclusive values or expressing a commitment to equality:

  • It requires us to examine the everyday experiences of the people within our communities.
  • It requires us to recognise that language matters, behaviours matter and silence matters.
  • It requires us to develop the consciousness to notice exclusion, the confidence to challenge it and the competence to respond effectively.
  • And it requires us to recognise that inclusive leadership is not simply about creating environments where people feel welcome.

It is about creating cultures where their dignity is respected, their identities are affirmed, their experiences are validated and their safety is protected. The conversations I had with Black and neurodivergent educators, alongside the reflections shared by my student helper, were important reminders that we cannot assume our intentions are universally experienced – we must be willing to listen to perspectives that challenge our understanding of the cultures we lead.

As I look ahead to further conversations with international school leaders, particularly around the relationship between inclusion and safeguarding, I am reminded that these responsibilities cannot be separated from the cultures we create:

  • We cannot claim to cultivate belonging while overlooking the language and behaviours that undermine it.
  • We cannot expect individuals to feel psychologically safe if challenging discrimination comes at a personal or professional cost.
  • And we cannot build inclusive cultures if accountability depends upon who is speaking, who is listening or who is being challenged.

So perhaps the most important question for us all is this: When we witness language or behaviour that undermines someone’s dignity, identity or sense of belonging, are we prepared to move from being a bystander to becoming an upstander?

Because inclusion is not simply about what we stand for – it is also about what we are prepared to stand up against, and that is how we begin shaping intention into impact.

Continue the Conversation

At The Belonging Effect, we support schools, trusts and international education communities to develop inclusive leadership, facilitate courageous conversations and cultivate cultures of belonging.

Our workshops on Challenging Derogatory Language and Challenging Microaggressions provide educators with practical strategies to recognise bias, challenge discrimination and strengthen their confidence in responding to harmful language and behaviours.

Our mantra is Shaping Intention into Impact.

Explore our training, consultancy and resources at www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk.


Human-Centred Leadership: Who Belongs, Who Is Represented and Whose Voice Is Heard?

Hannah Wilson portrait

Written by Hannah Wilson

Founder and Director of the Belonging Effect (formerly Diverse Educators).

Reflections from the 33rd FOBISIA Annual Leadership Conference, Bangkok

Last weekend, I had the privilege of travelling to Bangkok to deliver a keynote and facilitate a workshop at the 33rd FOBISIA Annual Leadership Conference. The conference theme, Leading with Purpose in a Human-Centred World, provided a timely opportunity to reflect on the responsibilities we hold as educational leaders and the cultures we intentionally create.

My keynote, How Inclusive Is Our Leadership?, invited delegates to reflect on their consciousness, confidence and competence as inclusive leaders. My subsequent workshop, Committing to Inclusive Recruitment, explored how we can translate our commitment to diversity, equity, inclusion and belonging (DEIB) into more equitable recruitment practices.

I returned home feeling energised by the conversations, connections and commitment I encountered, but also reflecting on some important questions about representation, power, privilege and belonging.

As is often the case, the most valuable learning came not only from what was shared on the stage, but also from what I noticed, experienced and heard in the conversations between sessions.

A Welcoming Community, But Who Is Represented?

From the outset, I experienced FOBISIA as a warm, welcoming and values-aligned community. There was a genuine sense of connection between educational leaders, alongside a shared commitment to developing schools where young people can thrive.

I met leaders who were curious, reflective and open to challenge. Many were already engaging in meaningful work around DEIB, while others recognised that there was more to learn and more to do. This appetite for learning and improvement was encouraging.

However, I was also struck by the limited diversity of lived experience represented among the educational leaders attending the conference. There was greater diversity among the students who contributed to the event, which was important and encouraging. Yet, the representation of diverse identities and experiences within educational leadership was less evident.

I was not alone in noticing this. Several people approached me to share their reflections and express a desire to see greater representation within the community. This raised an important question: How can we create genuinely inclusive leadership communities if the diversity of the people within them does not reflect the diversity of the communities they serve?

Representation matters. It shapes whose perspectives inform decisions, whose experiences are understood and whose voices influence the direction of our schools. It also matters who is absent.

This is not about questioning the intentions of the leaders in the room. It is about recognising that our commitment to inclusion must extend beyond our values and aspirations to the structures, systems and opportunities that determine who gets to participate, contribute and lead.

Being Included Is Not the Same as Being Inclusive

I opened my keynote with two provocations:

  • We all believe we are inclusive. But how intentionally inclusive are we, really?
  • Being included is not the same as being inclusive.

These distinctions are fundamental to inclusive leadership.

When we experience belonging ourselves, it can be easy to assume that others share that experience. We may feel welcomed, valued, respected and included within our professional communities, without recognising that other people experience those same environments very differently.

Our own inclusion can become something we take for granted. Yet belonging is not universal, and it is certainly not experienced equally.

We need to move beyond asking whether we believe our schools are inclusive and start asking how inclusion is experienced by the people within them:

  • Who feels safe enough to speak?
  • Who feels confident enough to challenge?
  • Who can be authentic without fear of judgement?
  • Who feels visible, valued and represented?
  • And who is adapting, masking or code-switching simply to fit in?

Inclusive leadership requires us to recognise that our intentions and other people’s experiences are not necessarily aligned. The challenge is not simply to create cultures where we feel we belong, but to ensure that others can experience that same sense of belonging.

The Multiple Layers of Belonging in International Schools

One of my reflections from Bangkok was the complexity of belonging within international education. The leaders I met belong to multiple communities simultaneously:

  • They belong to FOBISIA, a professional network that connects schools and educational leaders across the region.
  • They belong to their individual schools, each with its own values, culture, history and identity.
  • Many also belong to wider school groups or educational brands, which bring additional expectations, systems and organisational cultures.
  • And they live and work within host countries, each with its own cultural, social, historical and political contexts.

These overlapping identities create opportunities for connection, collaboration and learning. However, they also require leaders to navigate different expectations, assumptions and power dynamics.

International schools are often inherently diverse communities. Their staff, students and families may represent multiple nationalities, ethnicities, languages, religions and cultural traditions, but we also know that diversity does not automatically create inclusion. Nor does internationalism automatically create cultural competence.

As leaders, we need to understand how our own cultural frames influence the way we interpret behaviour, communicate expectations, exercise authority and make decisions. We also need to recognise the differences between the cultures of our host countries and the educational systems, traditions and values that our schools may have inherited or imported:

  • Whose cultural norms are considered the default? 
  • Whose knowledge and experiences are privileged? 
  • Who is expected to adapt?

These are important questions for any school, but they have particular significance within international education.

Inclusive Leadership Requires Consciousness, Confidence and Competence

Throughout my keynote, I encouraged delegates to consider three interconnected dimensions of inclusive leadership which we call BE’s 3 C’s:

  • Consciousness: Developing greater awareness of ourselves, our identities, assumptions, biases, power and privilege. Recognising how these influence our leadership decisions and behaviours.
  • Confidence: Having the courage to ask difficult questions, engage in uncomfortable conversations, challenge inequity and hold ourselves and others accountable.
  • Competence: Developing the knowledge, skills and behaviours required to translate inclusive intentions into meaningful and sustainable change.

We explored Deloitte’s six signature traits of inclusive leadership, alongside Diversity Council Australia’s inclusive leadership model. Both reinforce the importance of curiosity, courage, cultural intelligence, collaboration and a willingness to challenge established practices. However, awareness alone is insufficient.

We can understand the importance of inclusion, articulate our values and demonstrate genuine compassion, yet still perpetuate inequitable practices if we are unwilling to examine and change the systems within which we operate.

Inclusive leadership requires us to:

  • Notice inequity.
  • Name inequity.
  • Respond to inequity.
  • Redesign the systems that reproduce inequity.

It is this final step that is often the most challenging as it requires us to move beyond individual behaviours and consider the structures, policies and processes that determine who has access to opportunities, influence and success.

Who Belongs Beyond the Leadership Team?

Another observation from the conference prompted me to reflect on hierarchy, status and belonging. 

There was a significant presence of exhibitors and partners supporting the event. As I moved between different spaces and conversations, I became conscious of a subtle separation between groups of attendees.

This was not necessarily intentional or unusual within a professional conference environment. However, it made me reflect on how easily we can create hierarchies of belonging, even within communities committed to inclusion:

  • Who is perceived as having status?
  • Whose contributions are recognised?
  • Who is invited into conversations?
  • Who is considered central to the community, and who remains on its periphery?

These reflections took me back to schools and, in particular, the experiences of support staff. Teaching assistants, administrative colleagues, technicians, site teams, catering staff, cleaners and other support professionals make an invaluable contribution to the daily life of our schools.

Yet how consistently are they included in professional learning, strategic conversations, staff consultation and school celebrations? Do they experience the same sense of belonging as teachers and senior leaders? Are their perspectives sought and valued when decisions are made? Do we recognise their expertise, or do organisational hierarchies inadvertently diminish their voices?

If we are serious about creating human-centred organisations, we need to consider the experiences of every human within them. Belonging cannot be determined by job title, professional status nor proximity to power.

Inclusive Recruitment: From Intention to Action

My workshop, Committing to Inclusive Recruitment, provided an opportunity to move from reflection to practical action.

If we recognise that our leadership teams do not always reflect the diversity of the communities they serve, we need to examine the processes through which people are recruited, selected, developed and promoted:

  • Who is attracted to our schools?
  • Who sees themselves represented in our leadership teams?
  • Who feels encouraged to apply?
  • What assumptions do we make about qualifications, experience, cultural fit and leadership potential?
  • And how might our existing recruitment practices unintentionally advantage some candidates while creating barriers for others?

Inclusive recruitment is not simply about increasing the diversity of applicants. It is about interrogating the entire recruitment journey, from how opportunities are advertised and candidates are shortlisted to how interviews are conducted and appointments are made.

It also requires us to consider what happens after someone joins our organisation as recruiting a more diverse workforce is only meaningful if we create the conditions in which people can belong, contribute, progress and thrive. 

We cannot recruit our way out of an exclusionary culture: Diversity may change who is in the room. Inclusion determines whose voice is heard. Equity influences whose opportunities are realised. Belonging shapes whether people feel valued enough to stay.

For international schools, these conversations are particularly important given the intersection of nationality, ethnicity, language, professional qualifications, recruitment pathways and local employment contexts.

The Courage to Challenge Compassionately

One of the most encouraging aspects of my experience was the feedback I received following my keynote and workshop. Several delegates commented on my passion for the work and the way I challenged their thinking while remaining compassionate and constructive. This matters to me as I believe inclusive leadership requires us to hold space for both challenge and care.

We need to create environments where people feel psychologically safe enough to acknowledge what they do not know, reflect on their assumptions and recognise where they may have contributed to inequity, but psychological safety must not become an excuse for avoiding difficult, or what I call courageous, conversations.

We need to be willing to challenge established thinking, question existing practices and hold one another accountable – compassion does not mean avoiding discomfort and courage does not require confrontation. We can challenge without shaming, we can disagree without diminishing and we can hold people accountable while preserving their dignity.

Indeed, some of the most meaningful professional learning happens when people feel sufficiently safe to be vulnerable and sufficiently challenged to reconsider their perspectives. The appetite for these conversations among the FOBISIA delegates I met was heartening – it reminded me that we do not need everyone to have all the answers, we just need leaders who are prepared to keep asking better questions.

From Human-Centred Intentions to Inclusive Impact

As I reflected on my time in Bangkok, I returned to the central theme of the conference: Leading with Purpose in a Human-Centred World.

What does it really mean to be a human-centred leader?

For me, it means recognising the humanity, dignity and individuality of everyone we lead. It means understanding that our experiences of an organisation are shaped by our identities, relationships, opportunities and proximity to power. It means being curious about the experiences of people whose perspectives differ from our own. And it means having the courage to change our behaviours and systems when we discover that our good intentions are not translating into equitable experiences.

During my keynote, I asked delegates a final provocation: Who crosses your threshold to give you honest feedback?

It is a question I believe every leader should reflect on:

  • Who feels safe enough to tell us when something is not working?
  • Who will challenge our assumptions?
  • Whose perspectives are missing from our conversations?
  • And, perhaps most importantly, what do we do when someone has the courage to tell us something we would rather not hear?

Listening is important, but listening without action risks becoming performative – the true measure of inclusive leadership is not simply whether we invite feedback, but whether we are prepared to change because of what we hear.

Final Reflections: What Will We Do Differently?

I left Bangkok grateful for the welcome I received, the relationships I developed and the opportunity to contribute to a community of educational leaders committed to making a difference. I also left with a renewed appreciation of the importance of representation, the complexity of belonging and the responsibility we all share for creating more equitable educational communities.

My reflections are offered in the same spirit as my keynote: with curiosity, compassion and a commitment to collective learning. For the FOBISIA community, and indeed for educational leaders everywhere, I would encourage us to consider:

  • Representation: Who is currently represented within our leadership communities, and whose lived experiences are missing?
  • Belonging: How do different groups of staff and students experience our organisational cultures?
  • Power and privilege: Who holds influence, whose voices shape decisions and who remains on the margins?
  • Recruitment: How intentionally are we removing barriers to accessing, developing and progressing into leadership?
  • Accountability: How do we know whether our inclusive intentions are translating into meaningful impact?

Human-centred leadership is not simply about being kind, approachable or well-intentioned – it requires consciousness, confidence and competence. It requires curiosity, courage and a commitment to continuous improvement. Above all, it requires us to recognise that being included is not the same as being inclusive – we cannot assume that because we belong, everybody else does too.

At The Belonging Effect, our mantra is Shaping Intention into Impact and my time in Bangkok reinforced why this matters. Belonging is not something we can simply declare within our values, articulate within our strategies or celebrate at our conferences – it is something that must be experienced by the people within our communities, including those whose voices we do not always hear. 

The question is not simply whether we believe we are inclusive leaders. It is whether the people we lead would agree.

Continue the Conversation

At The Belonging Effect, we support educational leaders and organisations to develop inclusive leadership practices, create equitable workplaces and cultivate cultures of belonging.

Explore our resources:

Shaping Intention into Impact.


The Belonging Effect: From Reflection to Responsibility, From Intention to Impact

Hannah Wilson portrait

Written by Hannah Wilson

Founder and Director of the Belonging Effect (formerly Diverse Educators).

Six lenses on belonging, six leadership commitments and one collective responsibility.

Belonging is a word we hear increasingly frequently in conversations about education, leadership, organisational culture and inclusion. But what does belonging really mean? Who gets to experience it? Who defines it? And, perhaps most importantly, how do we know when our intentions to cultivate belonging are having the impact we hope for?

Over the past six weeks, Aisha Thomas, Founder of Representation Matters, has facilitated a thoughtful LinkedIn series entitled The Belonging Effect, exploring belonging through six interconnected lenses: belonging, psychological safety, identity, voice, recognition and language. Thank you, Aisha, for contributing to this important conversation and encouraging people to reflect on the relationship between belonging and power.

At The Belonging Effect, these questions resonate deeply with our work supporting schools, trusts and organisations to cultivate inclusive cultures. They also connect with the themes explored in my book, Cultivating Belonging in Schools, and our current seven-part blog series examining the Department for Education’s recent research into school belonging.

One of the challenges of working in diversity, equity, inclusion and belonging (DEIB) is that we can become very good at asking questions, identifying barriers and articulating aspirations, but reflection alone does not change culture.

The challenge is how we translate our awareness into responsibility, our responsibility into action and our actions into measurable impact.

So, building on these six themes, I want to explore six commitments that leaders can make to move beyond conversations about belonging towards cultivating the conditions in which everyone can experience it.

  1. From Welcome to Belonging: Understanding Lived Experience

We often use the words diversity, inclusion and belonging interchangeably, but they are not synonymous. An organisation can be diverse without being inclusive. It can be welcoming without everyone feeling welcome. And it can articulate a commitment to belonging while some members of its community continue to experience exclusion.

Belonging is not simply about being invited into a space. It is about feeling safe, recognised, respected, valued and able to contribute meaningfully within it. This distinction matters because organisational intentions do not necessarily reflect individual experiences.

A school might pride itself on being inclusive, yet some pupils may not see their identities represented in the curriculum. A workplace might celebrate diversity, yet colleagues from marginalised groups may experience barriers to progression or participation. We must therefore resist the temptation to measure belonging solely through the lens of those who hold power or occupy positions of privilege.

Leadership commitment: Listen to and understand the different experiences of belonging across your organisation.

From intention to impact: Gather meaningful stakeholder voice, explore differences in experience and identify what needs to change. Revisit those experiences over time to understand whether your actions are making a difference.

Reflective question: Who might experience our organisational culture differently from the way we believe it is experienced?

  1. From Psychological Safety to Collective Accountability

Psychological safety is fundamental to cultivating belonging. Amy Edmondson’s research reminds us of the importance of creating environments where people feel able to speak up, ask questions, acknowledge mistakes and challenge decisions without fear of humiliation or interpersonal punishment. Psychological safety is not simply about being comfortable – it requires us to consider the relationship between power, trust and the consequences of speaking honestly:

  • Who can challenge a decision without risking their reputation? 
  • Who feels able to disagree with a senior leader? 
  • Who remains silent because previous experiences have taught them that speaking up comes at a cost?
  • And what happens when somebody does find the courage to challenge?

Psychological safety must be accompanied by relational safety, accountability and a willingness to respond constructively to uncomfortable truths. In our leadership development work, we often explore the relationship between high challenge and low threat. Strong relationships create the trust necessary for honest conversations, but high-performing teams also need clarity, consistency and collective accountability. 

We cannot claim to value courageous conversations while penalising those who demonstrate courage. Equally, creating psychologically safe environments does not mean avoiding difficult conversations nor removing constructive feedback and challenge.

Leadership commitment: Cultivate cultures where people feel safe to challenge, learn, disagree and hold one another accountable.

From intention to impact: Examine how leaders respond to mistakes, disagreement and challenge. Establish clear expectations for respectful dialogue and accountability, and regularly review whether people experience these consistently.

Reflective question: What happens in our organisation when somebody tells us something we do not want to hear?

  1. From Assimilation to Authenticity: Respecting Identity and Agency

We frequently encourage people to bring their whole selves to work. The intention is usually positive as we want people to feel accepted, respected and able to express their identities without fear of discrimination. However, authenticity should not become an expectation that individuals disclose more of themselves than they choose.

There is an important distinction between adaptation and assimilation – we all adapt our communication, behaviours and approaches according to different contexts. This is part of navigating professional and social relationships. The equity question is whether some people are required to adapt disproportionately to be accepted:

  • Who feels compelled to code-switch? 
  • Who modifies their accent, appearance or emotional expression? 
  • Who conceals aspects of their identity to avoid judgement? 
  • And who can participate without having to make comparable compromises?

We also need to recognise the intersectionality of our identities and experiences as race, gender, disability, religion, socioeconomic background, sexuality and other aspects of identity do not exist in isolation. They intersect to shape how individuals experience organisational cultures, opportunities and barriers.

Belonging should not require assimilation. Equally, authenticity should not require disclosure.

Leadership commitment: Create environments where people have agency over how they express their identities and participate within their communities.

From intention to impact: Review organisational expectations, policies and informal cultural norms. Challenge practices that disproportionately disadvantage particular groups and ensure that individuals have meaningful choice without fear of negative consequences.

Reflective question: Who is expected to change themselves to fit our culture, and what might that reveal about the culture we have created?

  1. From Voice to Influence: Listening That Leads to Change

We talk frequently about the importance of stakeholder voice – schools gather pupil, staff and parent feedback and organisations conduct employee surveys, listening exercises and consultations. But gathering voice is not the same as enabling influence:

  • We can invite people to contribute while continuing to make decisions without meaningfully considering their perspectives.
  • We can celebrate consultation while leaving existing power structures largely unchanged.
  • And we can repeatedly ask marginalised groups to share their experiences without demonstrating how their contributions have informed our decisions.

We need to be aware that this creates a significant risk as when people are invited to speak but see little evidence of change, consultation can undermine rather than strengthen trust. Meaningful voice activity instead requires us to listen with curiosity, acknowledge what we hear and demonstrate how it influences our thinking, decisions and actions. It also requires us to recognise whose voices may be missing as those who are most confident, articulate or comfortable speaking in established forums are not necessarily representative of the wider community.

Leadership commitment: Move beyond consultation towards meaningful participation, influence and shared responsibility.

From intention to impact: Establish transparent processes for gathering, responding to and acting upon stakeholder feedback. Communicate what has changed, what has not changed and why. Where appropriate, involve stakeholders in co-designing solutions and evaluating outcomes.

Reflective question: Whose voice has genuinely influenced our decisions, and how would they know?

  1. From Recognition to Mattering: Valuing Every Contribution

Being present is not the same as being recognised, and being recognised is not necessarily the same as feeling valued. The concept of mattering is particularly important here:

  • Belonging is about feeling connected to a community. 
  • Mattering is about knowing that we are significant within it, that our presence, experiences and contributions make a difference.

In every organisation, there is work that is highly visible and work that often goes unnoticed:

  • The colleague who supports others through difficult experiences. 
  • The person who challenges exclusion. 
  • The individual who builds relationships across teams. 
  • The employee who repeatedly provides informal guidance about identity, culture or discrimination.

These contributions help sustain organisational cultures, yet they are not always acknowledged, supported or rewarded.

Equally, visibility is not universally positive – for some individuals, being highly visible can mean being disproportionately scrutinised, expected to represent an entire community or recognised primarily for their identity rather than their expertise. So we need to consider not only who is recognised, but what they are recognised for and whether recognition is experienced equitably.

Leadership commitment: Ensure that everyone has opportunities to feel known, valued and recognised for their contributions without being tokenised or disproportionately burdened.

From intention to impact: Review how responsibilities, recognition, development opportunities and rewards are distributed. Consider whose contributions may be overlooked and whether particular individuals or groups are carrying disproportionate emotional or representational labour.

Reflective question: Whose contribution would we notice only if they stopped making it?

  1. From Inclusive Language to Inclusive Practice

Language shapes our perceptions, relationships and experiences as the words we choose communicate our expectations, assumptions and beliefs about ourselves and others. They can create connection, demonstrate respect and reinforce belonging. Equally, they can perpetuate stereotypes, reinforce power imbalances and communicate exclusion. Consider the difference between describing somebody as challenging or courageous, difficult or principled, disengaged or unheard.

Our language can influence how we interpret behaviour, allocate opportunities and respond to individuals, but inclusive communication requires more than choosing appropriate words. It also requires us to consider accessibility:

  • Who can access the information we share? 
  • Who can participate in the conversations we facilitate? 
  • And whose needs might we inadvertently overlook?

Whether we are publishing social media content, designing presentations, facilitating meetings or communicating with families, accessibility needs to be considered from the outset. This includes providing meaningful alternative text for informative images, using accessible formats, considering how emojis and visual content are interpreted by assistive technologies, and offering different ways for people to participate and contribute. There is little value in advocating for inclusion through communication that inadvertently excludes people.

Of course, none of us will get everything right all of the time. Inclusive leadership requires humility, openness to feedback and a willingness to learn.

Leadership commitment: Ensure that inclusive language is accompanied by accessible communication and equitable organisational practice.

From intention to impact: Review communication practices, accessibility standards and the language used in policies, meetings and everyday interactions. Invite feedback, address barriers and make accessibility a shared responsibility rather than an afterthought.

Reflective question: Who might be excluded from our conversations, not because of what we are saying, but because of how we are communicating?

The Golden Thread: Power, Privilege and Responsibility

Across these six themes, one issue consistently emerges: power. Power shapes whose experiences are prioritised, whose voices are heard, whose identities are recognised and whose contributions are valued. It influences who feels safe to challenge, who has access to opportunities and who gets to define what belonging looks like.

For leaders, this requires us to reflect on our own positionality, privileges and spheres of influence. But recognising power is only the beginning – the real challenge is understanding how we use the power we hold:

  • Do we use it to protect existing systems and structures, or to challenge inequities?
  • Do we create opportunities for others to participate meaningfully in decisions?
  • Are we willing to acknowledge that our good intentions may not be experienced positively by everyone?
  • And perhaps most importantly, are we prepared to change our own behaviours, practices and assumptions in response to what we discover?

Inclusive leadership is not simply about what we believe. It is demonstrated through what we consistently do.

From Conversation to Collective Action

There is growing recognition across education and other sectors that belonging matters. The Department for Education’s recent School Belonging Case Studies Research offers further insight into how belonging is cultivated through relationships, safety, inclusion, individual recognition and collective identity. The research reinforces something we have long advocated at The Belonging Effect: belonging is not a standalone initiative, a policy to implement nor a destination to reach. It is cultivated through the relationships we build, the cultures we create, the systems we challenge and the decisions we make.

It is important that we also recognise that belonging cannot simply be declared by those in positions of leadership. We need to understand how it is experienced by those within our communities, particularly those whose voices have historically been marginalised or overlooked. This requires us to move through a continuous cycle:

Intention → Reflection → Listening → Action → Evaluation → Accountability

We need to ask meaningful questions, but we also need to be prepared to respond to the answers. We need to create opportunities for dialogue, but we also need to ensure that dialogue leads to decisions. And we need to articulate our commitment to belonging, but we also need to evaluate whether our actions are changing people’s experiences.

Six Questions for Leaders

As you reflect on these six dimensions of belonging, I invite you to consider:

  1. Belonging: Who experiences our organisational culture differently from how we intend it to be experienced?
  2. Psychological safety: Who feels safe enough to challenge, disagree and tell us uncomfortable truths?
  3. Identity and agency: Who feels pressure to change or conceal aspects of themselves to be accepted?
  4. Voice and influence: Whose perspectives genuinely shape our decisions and actions?
  5. Recognition and mattering: Whose contributions are valued, recognised and rewarded, and whose are overlooked?
  6. Language and accessibility: Who can fully access, understand and participate in our communications and conversations?

And one final question that brings them together: What are we prepared to change because of what we have learned?

Final Reflections: Shaping Intention into Impact

I welcome the growing conversations about belonging across our professional communities. We need diverse perspectives, constructive debates, shared learning and opportunities to reconsider our assumptions. 

We also need to remember that belonging is both a personal experience and a collective responsibility. We will not always agree… We will not always get things right… And we will sometimes need to navigate uncomfortable conversations, competing perspectives and challenging relationships. How we respond in those moments is often as revealing as the values we articulate.

Cultivating belonging requires curiosity, courage, compassion and accountability. It requires us to listen without becoming defensive, challenge without diminishing others and recognise that our experiences are not necessarily representative of everyone else’s. Above all, it requires action, because the measure of our commitment to belonging is not simply the conversations we facilitate or the intentions we articulate.

It is the difference our leadership makes to the lived experiences of others.

At The Belonging Effect, our mantra is Shaping Intention into Impact. And that is the challenge I would leave us all with – not simply asking whether people belong, but considering what we are doing, individually and collectively, to ensure that they do.

Continue the Conversation

At The Belonging Effect, we support schools, trusts and organisations to cultivate inclusive cultures where belonging can be experienced, strengthened and measured. Through leadership development, consultancy, training and strategic support, we work with leaders to move beyond good intentions and create meaningful, sustainable change.

Explore our work and resources at www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk.

References and Further Reading

  • Thomas, A. (2026). The Belonging Effect. Six-part LinkedIn series. Read the concluding post.
  • Department for Education (2026). School Belonging Case Studies Research. Research conducted by Ipsos in partnership with TONIC, Professor Kathryn Riley and the Anna Freud Centre.
  • Edmondson, A. (2019). The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation, and Growth. Wiley.
  • Wilson, H. (2026). Cultivating Belonging in Schools.
  • The Belonging Effect (2026). Belonging in Practice: What Can We Learn from the DfE Research?.


Leading SEND with Systemic Empathy

Kate Hinks portrait

Written by Kate Hinks

Kate Hinks is Head of SEND in a multi-academy trust, with a career spanning mainstream, specialist and alternative provision. She has worked as a Specialist Advisory Teacher, SENCO and ASC Resource Base Leader, and has experience in PRU and SEMH settings.

Sometimes, at the end of the day, I sit down with my husband and say:

“I made three people cry today.”

Inevitably, he makes a joke about either my dreadfully cruel personality, personal body odour or how I bore them all to tears at home too.

But, of course, those aren’t the real reasons those people were crying (I hope!!). Instead, it’s usually one of the following:

  • The frustration of the parent who is sick of fighting the system and feels that no one is helping them.
  • The overwhelm of the SENCO who feels like they are spinning a million plates and making no impact (of course they are, but it’s not always easy to see).
  • The embarrassment of the teacher who was observed struggling to meet the wide range of need in their class.

And in all those cases, the reason the often-bottled tears have finally been shed is because someone has taken the time to show them some empathy.To see their very real pain, acknowledge it, name it and tell them it’s OK to feel it.

By showing empathy in my role, I’ve prevented complaints, I’ve prevented resignations and, once or twice, I’ve prevented open warfare being declared in the classroom.

I am utterly convinced of the power of empathy. I’m convinced that it is essential in all leadership, but definitely in SEND leadership.

Empathy helps us understand what the daily lives of children with additional needs might be like, build trust with families, create safe cultures in teams and lead change without losing sight of the people it will impact.

But there is a question that has been increasingly bothering me:

How can we, as leaders, share in so much pain without suffering ourselves?

Empathy is not the same as sympathy. And neither is the same as compassion.

For me, empathy is about seeking to understand another person’s experience and emotional reality. Sympathy is feeling concern for someone. Compassion takes us one step further: recognising suffering and wanting to do something to ease it.

In SEND leadership, we need all three.

But they come with a cost.

It takes a huge amount of strength and skill to be empathetic as a leader: to recognise that those you lead are struggling but still hold them to account; to show understanding without rescuing; to challenge without humiliating; and to listen without promising.

The cost of this on a leader can be immense.

Women are more empathetic, right?

Most of the SEND leaders in Excalibur and nationally are women. (19/20 in Excalibur and 94% nationally)- 

That’s because women are more empathetic, right?

There is evidence that women and girls score higher, on average, on some measures of emotional intelligence and emotion recognition. A major 2026 meta-analysis examined 1,279 articles, 1,428 samples and more than 609,000 participants across 76 countries. It found average female advantages in several emotional abilities, particularly other-focused abilities such as recognising and understanding emotion.

That matters.

Because saying “women are more empathetic” is quite different from saying “women may, on average, demonstrate strengths in some emotional abilities.”

But neither conclusion tells us that women should therefore be responsible for managing the feelings of everyone around them.

And yet research consistently finds that women are stereotyped as being more emotional and communal than men.

In leadership, this creates a problematic double bind.

  • We are expected to care… but not too much.
  • We are expected to be warm… but also authoritative.
  • We are expected to listen… but also to make the decision.
  • We are expected to understand everyone’s perspective… but still to hold people accountable.

Women leaders can be penalised for displaying emotions associated with dominance, such as anger, but can also be penalised for appearing too soft and cuddly to be taken serious as leaders.

Research for the Department for Education found that female teachers were more likely than male teachers to leave teaching while of working age. And when women did leave, they were more likely than men to move into teaching assistant roles or lower-paid occupations, while men were more likely to move into professional and managerial roles outside education.

So perhaps the question isn’t “Are women better at caring?”

Perhaps it is:

What happens when a profession becomes increasingly dependent on the people who are culturally expected to care?

From empathetic individuals to an empathetic system

If empathy is a strength of SEND leadership, but women are disproportionately expected to provide emotional labour, how do we keep the strength without paying the personal cost?

I think part of the answer lies in how we think about SEND leadership itself.

We are going through a national shift in how we think about SEND and inclusion. Leadership is increasingly understood as something that must be distributed across all leaders and stakeholders within the education system, rather than sitting with the SENCO or a single inclusion leader.

I think the same needs to be true of empathy.

If we recognise that SEND leadership requires empathy, but a school or Trust depends on a few exceptionally empathetic people to hold everything together, we haven’t created a distributed, empathetic SEND system.

We’ve created a system that relies on particular individuals to absorb its emotional load.

And even the best of these individuals won’t last long. 

The SENCO shouldn’t be the only person who knows how to listen to a distressed parent. The inclusion leader shouldn’t be the only person who can have a difficult conversation about need. The headteacher shouldn’t be the only person holding the emotional temperature of the school. And the woman who has become everyone’s safe pair of hands shouldn’t have to be the emotional shock absorber for the whole organisation.

We need cultures where empathy is distributed. Where every leader understands that listening is part of leadership. Where difficult conversations are approached with dignity. Where staff can say, “I’m struggling,” without being seen as incapable. Where families don’t have to reach crisis point before someone listens. Where challenge and compassion can coexist. And where the people leading inclusion are given the same care, support and psychological safety that we expect them to create for everyone else. 

Because empathy shouldn’t depend on whether the person in front of you happens to be an unusually caring woman. It should be how we lead.

Perhaps the real ambition isn’t to make women better at carrying the emotional weight of SEND. Perhaps it is to build a system where no one has to carry it alone.


Celebrating Diversity and Challenging Discrimination: Creating Schools Where Everyone Belongs

Belonging Effect Favicon

Written by Belonging Effect

Belonging Effect is committed to shaping intention into impact and supporting people with their Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, & Belonging strategy and training needs.

Belonging in Practice | Part 3 of 7

Belonging is not about fitting in. It is about being recognised, respected and valued for who we are.

Over the past two weeks, we have been exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s (DfE) recently published School Belonging Case Studies Research. We began by considering what belonging means in practice, before examining the importance of relationships, trust, psychological safety and connection.

This week, we turn our attention to the third area of practice identified in the research: celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination.

The research highlights the importance of meaningfully embedding pupils’ cultures and identities throughout the curriculum and wider school life, alongside a compassionate, zero-tolerance approach to discrimination. This is a welcome recognition that belonging cannot be cultivated without addressing issues of identity, representation, equity and inclusion. But it also raises some important questions:

  • What does it really mean to celebrate diversity? 
  • How do we move beyond representation towards meaningful inclusion? 
  • And how do we ensure that our commitment to challenging discrimination is experienced consistently across our school communities?

Belonging Is Not the Same as Fitting In

One of the most important distinctions we can make when discussing belonging is the difference between belonging and fitting in:

  • Fitting in often requires individuals to adapt themselves to the expectations, behaviours and norms of the dominant culture.
  • Belonging, however, should enable individuals to participate fully without compromising their identities.

This distinction is particularly important in schools, where children and young people are developing their understanding of themselves, their relationships and their place in the world.

When pupils feel that aspects of their identity need to be hidden, minimised or changed to gain acceptance, we must question whether they are genuinely experiencing belonging. This may relate to their race, ethnicity, religion, gender, sexuality, disability, neurodivergence, socioeconomic background or family circumstances. And, crucially, these identities do not exist in isolation.

We cannot claim to cultivate belonging while expecting individuals to leave aspects of themselves at the school gates. Creating inclusive school cultures requires us to recognise and value difference, while challenging the assumptions, stereotypes and inequalities that can prevent individuals from participating fully.

Celebrating Diversity: Beyond the Calendar

Many schools work hard to celebrate diversity – they organise cultural events, recognise religious festivals, celebrate awareness months and create displays that reflect the richness of their communities.

These activities can provide valuable opportunities for learning, connection and celebration. However, we must also consider whether diversity is meaningfully embedded throughout the school year or confined to particular events and occasions:

  • Does our curriculum reflect diverse histories, cultures, identities and contributions?
  • Are pupils exposed to a range of authors, artists, scientists, historians, leaders and role models?
  • Do we challenge stereotypes and dominant narratives, or inadvertently reinforce them?
  • Are different family structures, languages, beliefs and lived experiences recognised as part of everyday school life?
  • And whose stories remain absent?

A diverse curriculum is not simply about adding more representation. It is about examining whose knowledge is valued, whose perspectives are centred and whose contributions are recognised. For example, celebrating Black History Month is important, but Black history should not be confined to October. Recognising International Women’s Day has value, but women’s achievements and experiences should be embedded throughout the curriculum. Similarly, acknowledging religious festivals can strengthen understanding, but genuine religious inclusion also requires us to consider how school routines, expectations and practices accommodate different beliefs.

Celebrating diversity should not be an occasional activity. It should be an everyday experience.

From Representation to Inclusion

Representation matters – seeing people who share aspects of our identities reflected in the curriculum, school environment and wider community can strengthen our sense of recognition and belonging, but representation alone does not guarantee inclusion:

  • A pupil may see their culture celebrated in an assembly while experiencing discriminatory language in the playground.
  • A school may display inclusive values while some families feel excluded from decision-making.
  • A member of staff may see diversity reflected in recruitment materials while experiencing barriers to professional development or progression.

This is where we need to move beyond visibility and consider lived experience:

  • Are pupils able to participate meaningfully?
  • Are their perspectives listened to and acted upon?
  • Do they experience fairness in how expectations, opportunities, rewards and sanctions are applied?
  • Are staff from different backgrounds equally recognised, supported and empowered?
  • Do families experience genuine partnership, or are some voices heard more readily than others?

Representation is about being visible. Inclusion is about being valued, involved and empowered.

Both are essential, but neither should be mistaken for the other.

Challenging Discrimination: Compassion and Accountability

The DfE research highlights the importance of a compassionate, zero-tolerance approach to discrimination. This combination deserves careful consideration.

Schools have a responsibility to challenge discriminatory language, attitudes and behaviours, whether these relate to racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia, transphobia, religious discrimination or other forms of prejudice. However, a commitment to zero tolerance must be more than a statement in a policy. It must be reflected in how schools prevent discrimination, respond when incidents occur, support those who experience harm and hold individuals accountable.

There is also an important distinction between challenging discriminatory behaviour and labelling children as inherently discriminatory. Children and young people are developing their understanding of identity, difference, power and relationships. They may repeat language they have heard without fully understanding its meaning or impact. This does not mean that discriminatory behaviour should be excused or minimised. It means that our responses should combine clear boundaries, education, accountability and appropriate support.

We need to consider:

  • How do we respond when discriminatory language or behaviour occurs?
  • Do pupils and staff feel safe to report concerns?
  • Are incidents recorded, monitored and addressed consistently?
  • Do we recognise patterns of discrimination, rather than treating every incident as isolated?
  • Are those who experience discrimination listened to, supported and protected?
  • Do our responses enable learning and change without minimising the harm caused?

Compassion does not mean avoiding difficult conversations or consequences. Equally, accountability should not mean abandoning our commitment to education, dignity and growth.

We can challenge behaviour without dehumanising individuals. We can demonstrate compassion without compromising accountability.

Understanding Intersectionality

An important consideration when cultivating belonging is recognising that identities and experiences intersect. Kimberlé Crenshaw’s concept of intersectionality provides a valuable framework for understanding how different forms of inequality and discrimination can overlap:

  • A Black girl may experience school differently from a Black boy.
  • A neurodivergent pupil from a disadvantaged socioeconomic background may encounter barriers that are not fully understood through a SEND lens alone.
  • A Muslim pupil with a disability may experience challenges related to religion, accessibility and representation.

These experiences cannot always be understood by considering individual characteristics separately. Yet schools frequently organise their approaches to inclusion around distinct categories. We may have separate strategies for SEND, disadvantage, racial equity, gender equality and other aspects of inclusion. 

While targeted approaches can be important, we must also consider how these priorities intersect as children do not experience their identities in separate compartments. Neither should our approaches to inclusion take a single-issue approach.

An intersectional approach requires us to be curious about individual experiences, interrogate patterns within our data and listen carefully to those whose perspectives may challenge our assumptions. It also requires us to recognise that pupils who share an identity will not necessarily share the same experiences.

Our responsibility is not to make assumptions about what individuals need because of who they are, but instead to understand their experiences and respond appropriately.

Pupil Voice: Listening, Learning and Acting

One of the six practice themes identified in the DfE research is pupil voice and agency. Although we are focusing on diversity and discrimination this week, pupil voice is integral to understanding whether our inclusive intentions are becoming lived experiences.

Schools cannot determine how inclusive they are simply by reviewing their policies, curriculum plans or displays. We need to ask the people experiencing our cultures:

  • Do pupils feel safe to be themselves?
  • Do they see their identities and experiences reflected in school life?
  • Do they feel respected by their peers and the adults around them?
  • Do they believe discrimination will be challenged consistently?
  • And, perhaps most importantly, do they believe that speaking up will lead to meaningful change?

However, we also need to consider whose voices are represented in our feedback mechanisms:

  • Are we listening primarily to confident, articulate pupils who already feel connected to school?
  • How do we hear from pupils who are disengaged, marginalised or reluctant to speak?
  • What opportunities do we create for anonymous feedback, smaller conversations and alternative forms of participation?
  • And what happens after pupils share their experiences?

Pupil voice without meaningful influence risks becoming consultation without change. Listening is important. Acting on what we hear is what demonstrates that people’s experiences matter.

Creating a Culture of Collective Responsibility

Celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination cannot be the responsibility of a single member of staff, department or working group. It requires collective ownership:

  • School leaders have a responsibility to establish clear expectations, allocate resources, provide professional learning and ensure that inclusive values are reflected in policies and decision-making.
  • Teachers and support staff have a responsibility to examine their curriculum, language, assumptions and everyday interactions.
  • Governors and trustees have a responsibility to provide strategic oversight and hold leaders accountable for the experiences of their communities.
  • Pupils also have an important role in shaping inclusive cultures through their relationships, behaviours and willingness to challenge prejudice.

But responsibility must be accompanied by support – we cannot assume that everyone has the knowledge, confidence or competence to recognise and respond effectively to discrimination. Professional learning needs to move beyond awareness towards developing the skills required for courageous conversations, inclusive decision-making and appropriate intervention.

We also need to create environments where adults can acknowledge gaps in their understanding, reflect on mistakes and continue learning – inclusive cultures are not created by people who never get things wrong. They are created by people who are prepared to recognise, challenge and change what is wrong.

Things to Consider This Week

As we reflect on how diversity is celebrated and discrimination is challenged within our school communities, we invite you to consider three questions.

  1. Who is represented?

Whose identities, histories, cultures and experiences are reflected in our curriculum, school environment and wider community? Whose stories might be missing, marginalised or misrepresented?

  1. Who experiences inclusion differently?

What do our pupils, staff and families tell us about their experiences of discrimination, fairness and belonging? Are we listening to those whose experiences may challenge our assumptions?

  1. What are we prepared to change?

What is one intentional action we could take this week to strengthen representation, challenge discrimination or remove a barrier to inclusion?

  • Perhaps it is reviewing a curriculum resource.
  • Perhaps it is examining patterns within behaviour or exclusion data.
  • Perhaps it is creating a safer opportunity for pupils to share their experiences.
  • Or perhaps it is challenging language or behaviour that has become normalised within our school community.

The important thing is that our commitment to diversity and inclusion is demonstrated through our actions, not simply our intentions.

Final Reflections

Celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination are interconnected responsibilities. We cannot meaningfully celebrate difference while allowing prejudice, discrimination or exclusion to go unchallenged. Equally, we cannot create inclusive cultures solely by responding to incidents of discrimination. 

We must also intentionally cultivate environments where diverse identities, experiences and contributions are recognised, respected and valued. This requires more than policies, displays, assemblies or awareness campaigns. It requires us to examine the cultures we create, the behaviours we tolerate, the voices we prioritise and the barriers we may inadvertently sustain. It requires curiosity, courage, compassion and accountability. And it requires us to recognise that belonging is not achieved by expecting everyone to become the same.

Belonging is cultivated when we create the conditions for everyone to be themselves, contribute meaningfully and experience dignity, equity and respect.

Continue the Conversation

This is Part 3 of The Belonging Effect’s seven-week series, Belonging in Practice, exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s School Belonging Case Studies Research.

Next Monday, we will explore Cultivating a Strong School Identity, considering how shared values, collective purpose and school communities can strengthen belonging without compromising individuality.

At The Belonging Effect, we support schools and organisations to move beyond good intentions and create cultures where belonging can be experienced, strengthened and measured.

Shaping Intention into Impact.

References and Further Reading

Department for Education (2026). School Belonging Case Studies Research. Research conducted by Ipsos in partnership with TONIC, Professor Kathryn Riley and the Anna Freud Centre.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/school-belonging-case-studies-research

Crenshaw, K. (1989). Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum.

The Belonging Effect: www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk


Beyond the margins of silence: Pride Groups as opportunities for student voice

Pride and Progress logo

Written by Pride & Progress

Pride & Progress is a podcast, platform and community group working to amplify the voices of LGBTQ+ educators and explore how we can reimagine our educational spaces to be more inclusive for LGBTQ+ people.

Take a moment to think: where are the spaces in your life where you feel a real sense of belonging?

Perhaps it is with family, or friends, or friends who feel like family. Maybe it is in your workplace, sports teams, or faith spaces. Although it exists for all of us in varying places and forms, we all know what it feels like to belong somewhere.

Wherever it exists for us, that sense of belonging is important: to feel part of something, to feel safe somewhere, and to know that we are valued there. There are numerous factors which contribute to that feeling, many of which are explored in other blogs on Belonging Effect. But in our mind, one key thread in the tapestry of belonging is voice.

When we have a sense of voice in a space, we can make suggestions, give feedback, or raise concerns, knowing that they will be heard and respected. Without that sense of voice, we may find ourselves in the uncomfortable position of silence, or perhaps we may feel we have to leave the space altogether.

As educators, we are certain you want all your students to feel they have a voice in their school. This is not only important for their sense of belonging, but also a requirement of us, as set out in Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, which establishes the right of children to express their views and have those views considered in matters affecting them.

But is student voice an opportunity made equally available to all students?

This is one of the questions which inspired our recent research into LGBT+ student voice. We are Adam Brett and Jo Brassington, the team behind Pride & Progress, and much of our work focuses on exploring how we can make educational spaces more inclusive for LGBT+ students and staff. Our most recent work together has been a piece of research exploring LGBT+ student voice, and the role of Pride Groups. That research has recently been published by the British Educational Research Journal in an article we titled: Beyond the margins of silence: Pride Groups as opportunities for student voice.

In this paper we explore the literature regarding student voice and participation; student silence; and Pride Groups in school. We bring that literature together to share an original Dialogic Framework, which reveals the core elements and values needed to allow meaningful student voice and participation.

With this new framework outlined, we then employ it to analyse data collected by the University of Derby, who were appointed by the LGBT+ young people’s charity Just Like Us to monitor and evaluate their Pride Group programme. The analysis focuses on four schools, and includes data from focus groups, interviews, and observations. The critical analysis presents two clear arguments, and reaches one conclusion.

The Margins of Silence

Firstly, we demonstrate, through the lived experiences of LGBT+ students spoken to in the research, that traditional approaches to student voice do not always capture LGBT+ students’ experiences, and thus they are often positioned at the margins of silence in their schools.

Student Groups as Opportunities for Voice

Secondly, we explore four case study schools which each operate student Pride Groups to demonstrate that through such groups, LGBT+ students have the opportunity to move themselves from the margins of silence towards empowered and agentic voice and participation.

Conclusion

Brought together, these findings lead us to conclude that school Pride Groups are not only important pastoral support for minoritised students but also a powerful opportunity to move LGBT+ students from the margins of silence in their schools to a position of empowered and agentic voice and participation.

—

We started this blog by describing the importance of belonging and voice. This research demonstrates how student Pride Groups can be an opportunity for both, and it reveals the vital role that schools, educators, and organisations like Just Like Us play in enabling LGBT+ student voice through Pride Groups.

We are conscious you may be coming to this blog from various positions. If your school already has an active Pride Group, then this paper will offer suggestions of how you might strengthen that group and use it as an opportunity for empowering voice. If you are considering starting a Pride Group, then this paper offers you a research-informed argument to take to leadership which shows why you should be supported to do so. If you are critical of school Pride Groups, or have not yet understood their importance, then perhaps this article will offer you an alternative perspective.

This research is available open access and can be read and shared by anybody here: https://bera-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/berj.70288


Privacy Preference Center