Pride and Progress logo

Written by Pride & Progress

Pride & Progress is a podcast, platform and community group working to amplify the voices of LGBTQ+ educators and explore how we can reimagine our educational spaces to be more inclusive for LGBTQ+ people.

Take a moment to think: where are the spaces in your life where you feel a real sense of belonging?

Perhaps it is with family, or friends, or friends who feel like family. Maybe it is in your workplace, sports teams, or faith spaces. Although it exists for all of us in varying places and forms, we all know what it feels like to belong somewhere.

Wherever it exists for us, that sense of belonging is important: to feel part of something, to feel safe somewhere, and to know that we are valued there. There are numerous factors which contribute to that feeling, many of which are explored in other blogs on Belonging Effect. But in our mind, one key thread in the tapestry of belonging is voice.

When we have a sense of voice in a space, we can make suggestions, give feedback, or raise concerns, knowing that they will be heard and respected. Without that sense of voice, we may find ourselves in the uncomfortable position of silence, or perhaps we may feel we have to leave the space altogether.

As educators, we are certain you want all your students to feel they have a voice in their school. This is not only important for their sense of belonging, but also a requirement of us, as set out in Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, which establishes the right of children to express their views and have those views considered in matters affecting them.

But is student voice an opportunity made equally available to all students?

This is one of the questions which inspired our recent research into LGBT+ student voice. We are Adam Brett and Jo Brassington, the team behind Pride & Progress, and much of our work focuses on exploring how we can make educational spaces more inclusive for LGBT+ students and staff. Our most recent work together has been a piece of research exploring LGBT+ student voice, and the role of Pride Groups. That research has recently been published by the British Educational Research Journal in an article we titled: Beyond the margins of silence: Pride Groups as opportunities for student voice.

In this paper we explore the literature regarding student voice and participation; student silence; and Pride Groups in school. We bring that literature together to share an original Dialogic Framework, which reveals the core elements and values needed to allow meaningful student voice and participation.

With this new framework outlined, we then employ it to analyse data collected by the University of Derby, who were appointed by the LGBT+ young people’s charity Just Like Us to monitor and evaluate their Pride Group programme. The analysis focuses on four schools, and includes data from focus groups, interviews, and observations. The critical analysis presents two clear arguments, and reaches one conclusion.

The Margins of Silence

Firstly, we demonstrate, through the lived experiences of LGBT+ students spoken to in the research, that traditional approaches to student voice do not always capture LGBT+ students’ experiences, and thus they are often positioned at the margins of silence in their schools.

Student Groups as Opportunities for Voice

Secondly, we explore four case study schools which each operate student Pride Groups to demonstrate that through such groups, LGBT+ students have the opportunity to move themselves from the margins of silence towards empowered and agentic voice and participation.

Conclusion

Brought together, these findings lead us to conclude that school Pride Groups are not only important pastoral support for minoritised students but also a powerful opportunity to move LGBT+ students from the margins of silence in their schools to a position of empowered and agentic voice and participation.

—

We started this blog by describing the importance of belonging and voice. This research demonstrates how student Pride Groups can be an opportunity for both, and it reveals the vital role that schools, educators, and organisations like Just Like Us play in enabling LGBT+ student voice through Pride Groups.

We are conscious you may be coming to this blog from various positions. If your school already has an active Pride Group, then this paper will offer suggestions of how you might strengthen that group and use it as an opportunity for empowering voice. If you are considering starting a Pride Group, then this paper offers you a research-informed argument to take to leadership which shows why you should be supported to do so. If you are critical of school Pride Groups, or have not yet understood their importance, then perhaps this article will offer you an alternative perspective.

This research is available open access and can be read and shared by anybody here: https://bera-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/berj.70288

Privacy Preference Center