
Written by Hannah Wilson
Founder and Director of the Belonging Effect (formerly Diverse Educators).
Six lenses on belonging, six leadership commitments and one collective responsibility.
Belonging is a word we hear increasingly frequently in conversations about education, leadership, organisational culture and inclusion. But what does belonging really mean? Who gets to experience it? Who defines it? And, perhaps most importantly, how do we know when our intentions to cultivate belonging are having the impact we hope for?
Over the past six weeks, Aisha Thomas, Founder of Representation Matters, has facilitated a thoughtful LinkedIn series entitled The Belonging Effect, exploring belonging through six interconnected lenses: belonging, psychological safety, identity, voice, recognition and language. Thank you, Aisha, for contributing to this important conversation and encouraging people to reflect on the relationship between belonging and power.
At The Belonging Effect, these questions resonate deeply with our work supporting schools, trusts and organisations to cultivate inclusive cultures. They also connect with the themes explored in my book, Cultivating Belonging in Schools, and our current seven-part blog series examining the Department for Education’s recent research into school belonging.
One of the challenges of working in diversity, equity, inclusion and belonging (DEIB) is that we can become very good at asking questions, identifying barriers and articulating aspirations, but reflection alone does not change culture.
The challenge is how we translate our awareness into responsibility, our responsibility into action and our actions into measurable impact.
So, building on these six themes, I want to explore six commitments that leaders can make to move beyond conversations about belonging towards cultivating the conditions in which everyone can experience it.
- From Welcome to Belonging: Understanding Lived Experience
We often use the words diversity, inclusion and belonging interchangeably, but they are not synonymous. An organisation can be diverse without being inclusive. It can be welcoming without everyone feeling welcome. And it can articulate a commitment to belonging while some members of its community continue to experience exclusion.
Belonging is not simply about being invited into a space. It is about feeling safe, recognised, respected, valued and able to contribute meaningfully within it. This distinction matters because organisational intentions do not necessarily reflect individual experiences.
A school might pride itself on being inclusive, yet some pupils may not see their identities represented in the curriculum. A workplace might celebrate diversity, yet colleagues from marginalised groups may experience barriers to progression or participation. We must therefore resist the temptation to measure belonging solely through the lens of those who hold power or occupy positions of privilege.
Leadership commitment: Listen to and understand the different experiences of belonging across your organisation.
From intention to impact: Gather meaningful stakeholder voice, explore differences in experience and identify what needs to change. Revisit those experiences over time to understand whether your actions are making a difference.
Reflective question: Who might experience our organisational culture differently from the way we believe it is experienced?
- From Psychological Safety to Collective Accountability
Psychological safety is fundamental to cultivating belonging. Amy Edmondson’s research reminds us of the importance of creating environments where people feel able to speak up, ask questions, acknowledge mistakes and challenge decisions without fear of humiliation or interpersonal punishment. Psychological safety is not simply about being comfortable – it requires us to consider the relationship between power, trust and the consequences of speaking honestly:
- Who can challenge a decision without risking their reputation?
- Who feels able to disagree with a senior leader?
- Who remains silent because previous experiences have taught them that speaking up comes at a cost?
- And what happens when somebody does find the courage to challenge?
Psychological safety must be accompanied by relational safety, accountability and a willingness to respond constructively to uncomfortable truths. In our leadership development work, we often explore the relationship between high challenge and low threat. Strong relationships create the trust necessary for honest conversations, but high-performing teams also need clarity, consistency and collective accountability.
We cannot claim to value courageous conversations while penalising those who demonstrate courage. Equally, creating psychologically safe environments does not mean avoiding difficult conversations nor removing constructive feedback and challenge.
Leadership commitment: Cultivate cultures where people feel safe to challenge, learn, disagree and hold one another accountable.
From intention to impact: Examine how leaders respond to mistakes, disagreement and challenge. Establish clear expectations for respectful dialogue and accountability, and regularly review whether people experience these consistently.
Reflective question: What happens in our organisation when somebody tells us something we do not want to hear?
- From Assimilation to Authenticity: Respecting Identity and Agency
We frequently encourage people to bring their whole selves to work. The intention is usually positive as we want people to feel accepted, respected and able to express their identities without fear of discrimination. However, authenticity should not become an expectation that individuals disclose more of themselves than they choose.
There is an important distinction between adaptation and assimilation – we all adapt our communication, behaviours and approaches according to different contexts. This is part of navigating professional and social relationships. The equity question is whether some people are required to adapt disproportionately to be accepted:
- Who feels compelled to code-switch?
- Who modifies their accent, appearance or emotional expression?
- Who conceals aspects of their identity to avoid judgement?
- And who can participate without having to make comparable compromises?
We also need to recognise the intersectionality of our identities and experiences as race, gender, disability, religion, socioeconomic background, sexuality and other aspects of identity do not exist in isolation. They intersect to shape how individuals experience organisational cultures, opportunities and barriers.
Belonging should not require assimilation. Equally, authenticity should not require disclosure.
Leadership commitment: Create environments where people have agency over how they express their identities and participate within their communities.
From intention to impact: Review organisational expectations, policies and informal cultural norms. Challenge practices that disproportionately disadvantage particular groups and ensure that individuals have meaningful choice without fear of negative consequences.
Reflective question: Who is expected to change themselves to fit our culture, and what might that reveal about the culture we have created?
- From Voice to Influence: Listening That Leads to Change
We talk frequently about the importance of stakeholder voice – schools gather pupil, staff and parent feedback and organisations conduct employee surveys, listening exercises and consultations. But gathering voice is not the same as enabling influence:
- We can invite people to contribute while continuing to make decisions without meaningfully considering their perspectives.
- We can celebrate consultation while leaving existing power structures largely unchanged.
- And we can repeatedly ask marginalised groups to share their experiences without demonstrating how their contributions have informed our decisions.
We need to be aware that this creates a significant risk as when people are invited to speak but see little evidence of change, consultation can undermine rather than strengthen trust. Meaningful voice activity instead requires us to listen with curiosity, acknowledge what we hear and demonstrate how it influences our thinking, decisions and actions. It also requires us to recognise whose voices may be missing as those who are most confident, articulate or comfortable speaking in established forums are not necessarily representative of the wider community.
Leadership commitment: Move beyond consultation towards meaningful participation, influence and shared responsibility.
From intention to impact: Establish transparent processes for gathering, responding to and acting upon stakeholder feedback. Communicate what has changed, what has not changed and why. Where appropriate, involve stakeholders in co-designing solutions and evaluating outcomes.
Reflective question: Whose voice has genuinely influenced our decisions, and how would they know?
- From Recognition to Mattering: Valuing Every Contribution
Being present is not the same as being recognised, and being recognised is not necessarily the same as feeling valued. The concept of mattering is particularly important here:
- Belonging is about feeling connected to a community.
- Mattering is about knowing that we are significant within it, that our presence, experiences and contributions make a difference.
In every organisation, there is work that is highly visible and work that often goes unnoticed:
- The colleague who supports others through difficult experiences.
- The person who challenges exclusion.
- The individual who builds relationships across teams.
- The employee who repeatedly provides informal guidance about identity, culture or discrimination.
These contributions help sustain organisational cultures, yet they are not always acknowledged, supported or rewarded.
Equally, visibility is not universally positive – for some individuals, being highly visible can mean being disproportionately scrutinised, expected to represent an entire community or recognised primarily for their identity rather than their expertise. So we need to consider not only who is recognised, but what they are recognised for and whether recognition is experienced equitably.
Leadership commitment: Ensure that everyone has opportunities to feel known, valued and recognised for their contributions without being tokenised or disproportionately burdened.
From intention to impact: Review how responsibilities, recognition, development opportunities and rewards are distributed. Consider whose contributions may be overlooked and whether particular individuals or groups are carrying disproportionate emotional or representational labour.
Reflective question: Whose contribution would we notice only if they stopped making it?
- From Inclusive Language to Inclusive Practice
Language shapes our perceptions, relationships and experiences as the words we choose communicate our expectations, assumptions and beliefs about ourselves and others. They can create connection, demonstrate respect and reinforce belonging. Equally, they can perpetuate stereotypes, reinforce power imbalances and communicate exclusion. Consider the difference between describing somebody as challenging or courageous, difficult or principled, disengaged or unheard.
Our language can influence how we interpret behaviour, allocate opportunities and respond to individuals, but inclusive communication requires more than choosing appropriate words. It also requires us to consider accessibility:
- Who can access the information we share?
- Who can participate in the conversations we facilitate?
- And whose needs might we inadvertently overlook?
Whether we are publishing social media content, designing presentations, facilitating meetings or communicating with families, accessibility needs to be considered from the outset. This includes providing meaningful alternative text for informative images, using accessible formats, considering how emojis and visual content are interpreted by assistive technologies, and offering different ways for people to participate and contribute. There is little value in advocating for inclusion through communication that inadvertently excludes people.
Of course, none of us will get everything right all of the time. Inclusive leadership requires humility, openness to feedback and a willingness to learn.
Leadership commitment: Ensure that inclusive language is accompanied by accessible communication and equitable organisational practice.
From intention to impact: Review communication practices, accessibility standards and the language used in policies, meetings and everyday interactions. Invite feedback, address barriers and make accessibility a shared responsibility rather than an afterthought.
Reflective question: Who might be excluded from our conversations, not because of what we are saying, but because of how we are communicating?
The Golden Thread: Power, Privilege and Responsibility
Across these six themes, one issue consistently emerges: power. Power shapes whose experiences are prioritised, whose voices are heard, whose identities are recognised and whose contributions are valued. It influences who feels safe to challenge, who has access to opportunities and who gets to define what belonging looks like.
For leaders, this requires us to reflect on our own positionality, privileges and spheres of influence. But recognising power is only the beginning – the real challenge is understanding how we use the power we hold:
- Do we use it to protect existing systems and structures, or to challenge inequities?
- Do we create opportunities for others to participate meaningfully in decisions?
- Are we willing to acknowledge that our good intentions may not be experienced positively by everyone?
- And perhaps most importantly, are we prepared to change our own behaviours, practices and assumptions in response to what we discover?
Inclusive leadership is not simply about what we believe. It is demonstrated through what we consistently do.
From Conversation to Collective Action
There is growing recognition across education and other sectors that belonging matters. The Department for Education’s recent School Belonging Case Studies Research offers further insight into how belonging is cultivated through relationships, safety, inclusion, individual recognition and collective identity. The research reinforces something we have long advocated at The Belonging Effect: belonging is not a standalone initiative, a policy to implement nor a destination to reach. It is cultivated through the relationships we build, the cultures we create, the systems we challenge and the decisions we make.
It is important that we also recognise that belonging cannot simply be declared by those in positions of leadership. We need to understand how it is experienced by those within our communities, particularly those whose voices have historically been marginalised or overlooked. This requires us to move through a continuous cycle:
Intention → Reflection → Listening → Action → Evaluation → Accountability
We need to ask meaningful questions, but we also need to be prepared to respond to the answers. We need to create opportunities for dialogue, but we also need to ensure that dialogue leads to decisions. And we need to articulate our commitment to belonging, but we also need to evaluate whether our actions are changing people’s experiences.
Six Questions for Leaders
As you reflect on these six dimensions of belonging, I invite you to consider:
- Belonging: Who experiences our organisational culture differently from how we intend it to be experienced?
- Psychological safety: Who feels safe enough to challenge, disagree and tell us uncomfortable truths?
- Identity and agency: Who feels pressure to change or conceal aspects of themselves to be accepted?
- Voice and influence: Whose perspectives genuinely shape our decisions and actions?
- Recognition and mattering: Whose contributions are valued, recognised and rewarded, and whose are overlooked?
- Language and accessibility: Who can fully access, understand and participate in our communications and conversations?
And one final question that brings them together: What are we prepared to change because of what we have learned?
Final Reflections: Shaping Intention into Impact
I welcome the growing conversations about belonging across our professional communities. We need diverse perspectives, constructive debates, shared learning and opportunities to reconsider our assumptions.
We also need to remember that belonging is both a personal experience and a collective responsibility. We will not always agree… We will not always get things right… And we will sometimes need to navigate uncomfortable conversations, competing perspectives and challenging relationships. How we respond in those moments is often as revealing as the values we articulate.
Cultivating belonging requires curiosity, courage, compassion and accountability. It requires us to listen without becoming defensive, challenge without diminishing others and recognise that our experiences are not necessarily representative of everyone else’s. Above all, it requires action, because the measure of our commitment to belonging is not simply the conversations we facilitate or the intentions we articulate.
It is the difference our leadership makes to the lived experiences of others.
At The Belonging Effect, our mantra is Shaping Intention into Impact. And that is the challenge I would leave us all with – not simply asking whether people belong, but considering what we are doing, individually and collectively, to ensure that they do.
Continue the Conversation
At The Belonging Effect, we support schools, trusts and organisations to cultivate inclusive cultures where belonging can be experienced, strengthened and measured. Through leadership development, consultancy, training and strategic support, we work with leaders to move beyond good intentions and create meaningful, sustainable change.
Explore our work and resources at www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk.
References and Further Reading
- Thomas, A. (2026). The Belonging Effect. Six-part LinkedIn series. Read the concluding post.
- Department for Education (2026). School Belonging Case Studies Research. Research conducted by Ipsos in partnership with TONIC, Professor Kathryn Riley and the Anna Freud Centre.
- Edmondson, A. (2019). The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation, and Growth. Wiley.
- Wilson, H. (2026). Cultivating Belonging in Schools.
- The Belonging Effect (2026). Belonging in Practice: What Can We Learn from the DfE Research?.
