Shilpa Darbar portrait

Written by Shilpa Darbar

With over a decade of experience as Head of History, Shilpa’s experience extends beyond classroom instruction to strategic leadership in curriculum development. She has reshaped the History curriculum to promote diversity and inclusiveness, a mission echoed in her published work with Impact and on her Substack. Her expertise in public speaking aids in advocating for educational innovation and elevating varied perspectives.

Conscious Curriculum Choices 

One of my proudest achievements as a Head of Department has been the diversification of our KS3 curriculum. When I first inherited the curriculum, I realised that many of the stories I had been taught as a pupil were the same ones I was now teaching my own students. That prompted an uncomfortable question: were we preparing young people to understand the world as it is today, or simply reproducing the curriculum we had inherited? 

The selection of historical periods, places and perspectives within the History curriculum is crucial, not only for fostering students’ engagement and enjoyment of the subject, but also for shaping what Victoria Elliott describes as ‘disciplinary powerful knowledge’ (Elliott, 2021, p. 8). The texts, sources and voices we include shape the culture of our curriculum, elevating certain values and perspectives while marginalising others. In their study of students aged 12–14, Harris and Reynolds found that ‘although many students enjoy History, they fail to fully understand its value […] especially those from minority ethnic backgrounds, [who] feel a lack of personal connection to the past, as they do not see themselves in the History they are taught’ (Harris and Reynolds, 2014, p. 46). Similarly, Barton and Levstik argue that a sense of identification is fundamental to the purpose of studying History, suggesting that students need to connect with the past at a personal, familial or national level (Barton and Levstik, 2004).  

Yet, in my experience, History in many UK schools has traditionally prioritised a national narrative of progress and achievement through a predominantly white lens. This was certainly true of my own primary and secondary school education, and although considerable progress has been made in recent years to broaden the curriculum, our work as educators is far from complete. As Bennie Kara argues, if the curriculum is “limited to the thoughts, experiences, histories and achievements of white, western Europe”, it denies students the opportunity to “view the truth of the world they live in” (Kara, 2021, p. 41). Heeding this advice means designing a curriculum that enables pupils to see their own experiences reflected while also developing an understanding of the lives and perspectives of others. Without this balance, we risk alienating some students and overlooking the rich diversity of experiences represented within our classrooms. 

Why tokenism isn’t enough 

Of course, recognising the need for greater representation does not mean simply adding a lesson on a famous South Asian historical figure during South Asian Heritage Month in July, or including a woman at the end of a unit that otherwise remains unchanged. Diversity is not something that can be bolted onto an existing curriculum as an afterthought. 

Tokenistic approaches often fail because they leave the underlying historical narrative untouched. They ask students to view certain individuals as exceptional rather than questioning why some stories have traditionally been centred while others have been marginalised. If we are serious about broadening students’ understanding of the past, we need to move beyond asking, Who can we add? Instead, we should ask, Why has this story been told in this way? 

In our department, diversification rarely meant creating entirely new units. More often, it meant asking different questions of the topics we already taught. 

For example, when teaching the British Empire, we asked, whose experiences were privileged? When studying the Industrial Revolution, whose voices were absent? When examining the World Wars, were we presenting them solely as British stories, or as global conflicts involving millions across the Empire and beyond? 

Sometimes the changes were substantial; often they were surprisingly small. A new enquiry question. A different source. A case study that challenged assumptions. Collectively, however, these decisions transformed the curriculum into one that better reflected both historical scholarship and the diversity of our classrooms. 

Diversification is about accuracy 

One of the strongest arguments for diversification isn’t actually representation, it’s accuracy. Modern historical scholarship has transformed our understanding of the past. Historians now pay far greater attention to women’s History, migration, empire, global History, everyday life and previously overlooked voices. If school curricula ignore these developments, they risk becoming outdated rather than rigorous. 

Curriculum diversification is therefore not simply a moral or pastoral project; it is an academic one. As historical scholarship develops, our curricula should develop alongside it. We would never continue teaching outdated interpretations simply because they are familiar. The same principle should apply to whose stories we choose to tell. Two key texts that shaped my thinking around this were David Olusoga’s Black and British: A Forgotten History (2016), and Sathnam Sanghera’s Empireland: How Imperialism Has Shaped Modern Britain (2021). These works questioned existing narratives in a way that really resonated with me personally and professionally.  

Putting diversification into practice 

Rather than simply introducing new topics, one of the most significant changes we made was embedding a recurring feature called ‘Meanwhile Elsewhere’ into every unit of study. At key points throughout each topic, students pause to explore what was happening elsewhere in the world at the same time. While studying the Norman Conquest, for example, they also learn about the flourishing kingdom of Benin in West Africa. This simple addition helps students move beyond seeing History through a solely British or European lens. It reinforces the idea that societies have always developed simultaneously, often influencing one another in complex ways, and encourages pupils to view the past as interconnected rather than a collection of isolated national stories.  

One of the clearest examples of our changing approach can be seen in our study of the British Empire. We wanted students to understand that empire was never simply a story of expansion, administration and economic growth. Alongside examining the development of the Empire itself, we deliberately foreground stories of resistance, resilience and the struggle for self-determination. Our in-depth study of the Indian independence movement allows students to encounter a range of voices and methods of resistance, from constitutional reformers like Nehru, to mass civil disobedience in the Quit India Movement led by Gandhi, while considering the profound consequences of colonial rule in both the short and long-term. By studying independence movements alongside imperial expansion, students gain a more balanced understanding of empire as a contested process, experienced very differently depending on whose perspective is being considered.  

The First World War provides another opportunity to broaden historical perspectives. For many students, the conflict is synonymous with trenches, mud and the Western Front. While these experiences remain central, we deliberately widen the lens by examining other theatres of war, including campaigns in Gallipoli, East Africa and the Middle East. We also explore the enormous contribution made by soldiers from across the British Empire, paying particular attention to the experiences of Indian troops who fought in Europe, Africa and the Middle East. This helps students recognise that the First World War was exactly that, a global conflict involving millions of people from across the world. It also prompts valuable discussions about why some contributions have traditionally been celebrated while others have been overlooked. 

Perhaps the most transformative change has been the way we teach migration. Rather than introducing migration as a post-war story beginning with Windrush, we present it as a continuous thread running throughout British History. From Year 7 onwards, students encounter migration chronologically, exploring how and why different groups have arrived in Britain across centuries—from Romans, Anglo-Saxons and Vikings to Huguenots, Jewish communities, Irish migrants, Commonwealth citizens and more recent arrivals. This approach enables pupils to trace patterns of continuity and change, examine the diverse reasons people migrate, and appreciate the lasting contributions migrant communities have made to British society. By the time students reach the twentieth century, they recognise that migration is not an exception in Britain’s past but one of the defining features of British history.   

A conscious choice 

Curriculum design is ultimately an act of choice. Every lesson we include means another cannot. Every source we select elevates one perspective over another. The question then is not whether our curriculum tells a story because it always will. The real question is: whose story are we choosing to tell? 

If our aim is to prepare young people to understand both the past and the diverse society in which they live, then perhaps the challenge is not to tell more stories, but to tell richer, more complete ones. 

Signposting

If you would like to learn more about how I approached managing this change, please see my article in Impact, Multidirectional narratives: Diversifying the English and History curriculums, (Darbar and Greenfield, 2022) 
https://my.chartered.college/impact_article/multidirectional-narratives-diversifying-the-english-and-history-curriculums/  

Privacy Preference Center