Belonging Effect Favicon

Written by Belonging Effect

Belonging Effect is committed to shaping intention into impact and supporting people with their Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, & Belonging strategy and training needs.

Belonging in Practice | Part 4 of 7

Strong school communities are built through shared values, collective identity and a sense of purpose. But genuine belonging requires us to celebrate individuality, not expect conformity.

Over the past three weeks, we have been exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s (DfE) recently published School Belonging Case Studies Research. We began by considering the importance of belonging as a whole-school culture, before examining relationships, trust and psychological safety, followed by the importance of celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination.

This week, we turn our attention to another area of practice identified in the research: cultivating a strong school identity. The research highlights how a unifying school ethos, shared values and smaller communities, such as house systems, can strengthen pupils’ sense of connection and collective identity. But this raises an important question: How do we create a strong sense of ‘we’ without losing sight of the individual ‘me’?

The Power of Collective Identity

One of the five dimensions of belonging identified in the DfE research is collective identity. Across the 16 case study schools, leaders, staff and pupils described the importance of feeling connected to something bigger than themselves. In primary schools, this was often articulated through the language of family, while secondary schools frequently emphasised community, shared identity and the role of house systems. These connections can provide pupils with a sense of security, pride and purpose. They communicate that we are part of a community where we matter, where our contributions are valued and where we share responsibility for one another.

For many pupils, school is one of the first places where they experience being part of a community beyond their immediate family. It provides opportunities to develop friendships, navigate differences, contribute to collective goals and understand their responsibilities towards others. However, a strong collective identity should not require individuals to suppress their differences. Belonging is not about becoming the same. It is about being connected while remaining ourselves. This distinction is fundamental to creating inclusive school cultures.

School Values: What We Say Versus What We Do

Most schools have a clearly articulated vision, mission and set of values. They are often displayed prominently on websites, walls, newsletters and prospectuses. We see words such as respect, kindness, integrity, courage, compassion and excellence. But how consistently are these values experienced?

A school may champion respect while some pupils experience discriminatory language…

It may promote kindness while staff feel unable to challenge decisions…

It may celebrate individuality while expecting everyone to conform to a narrow definition of acceptable behaviour…

It may articulate high expectations while failing to recognise the different barriers pupils encounter…

This is where we need to distinguish between espoused values and enacted values or as Mary Myatt says, values lived or values laminated. Espoused values describe what an organisation says it believes. Whereas, enacted values are demonstrated through its decisions, behaviours, relationships and everyday practices. The gap between the two can significantly influence how people experience belonging.

If we want our school values to be meaningful, we need to consider:

  • How are our values modelled by leaders and staff?
  • How are they reflected in our policies, curriculum and behaviour expectations?
  • How do they influence the way we respond to mistakes, conflict and challenge?
  • Are they experienced consistently by pupils, staff and families?
  • What happens when someone’s experience contradicts our stated values?

School culture is not defined by the values displayed on our walls. It is revealed through the behaviours experienced within them.

Creating Communities Within Communities

The DfE research highlights the value of smaller communities within larger schools, particularly through house systems. This is an important consideration as in large school communities, pupils can sometimes feel anonymous, disconnected or overlooked. Whereas smaller communities can provide opportunities for pupils to develop stronger relationships, experience recognition and contribute to a shared identity. 

House systems, tutor groups, mentoring programmes, clubs, enrichment activities and pupil leadership opportunities can all provide additional pathways to belonging. However, their effectiveness depends on how they are experienced. A house system may create pride and healthy competition, but does every pupil feel included?

  • A sports team may strengthen connection for those who participate, but what opportunities exist for pupils whose interests lie elsewhere?
  • A pupil leadership group may develop confidence and agency, but are the same confident and articulate pupils repeatedly selected?
  • A school may offer an impressive range of extracurricular activities, but are these equally accessible to pupils facing financial, social, cultural or additional needs-related barriers?

The question is not simply whether opportunities exist – it is whether everyone has a meaningful opportunity to participate.

Creating communities within communities only strengthens belonging when those communities are accessible, inclusive and valued. We should also recognise that pupils may experience belonging through different connections. For some, it may be their tutor group – for others, it may be a friendship group, a music ensemble, a lunchtime club or a trusted adult. There is no single pathway to belonging. The challenge is to create multiple opportunities for pupils to find connection, recognition and purpose.

Collective Identity Without Conformity

Strong school cultures often have established traditions, expectations and ways of doing things. Rituals and routines that can provide continuity, stability and a shared sense of identity. However, we must also be willing to examine whose identities and experiences have shaped those traditions:

  • Who decided what our school community should look, sound and behave like?
  • Whose values and perspectives are reflected?
  • Who finds it easy to participate?
  • And who may feel that belonging requires them to adapt, hide or compromise aspects of themselves?

This is particularly important when considering cultural, religious, racial, gender, socioeconomic and neurodivergent identities. For example, expectations around uniform, hairstyles, communication styles, participation or school traditions may be experienced differently across our communities. This does not mean that schools should abandon shared expectations. Rather, it means that we need to distinguish between expectations that promote safety, respect and collective responsibility, and those that may inadvertently reinforce conformity or exclusion.

A strong school identity should be sufficiently clear to create shared purpose, but sufficiently inclusive to accommodate differences – unity does not require uniformity. Indeed, the strength of a community can be measured by its ability to embrace different perspectives, experiences and identities while maintaining a shared commitment to its values.

Pupil Voice and Co-Creating School Culture

Another important theme within the DfE research is pupil voice and agency. This is particularly relevant when considering collective identity as if we want pupils to feel ownership of their school community, they need meaningful opportunities to influence it. 

Too often, school identity is something that is created by adults and communicated to pupils. We establish the vision, define the values, develop the expectations and then encourage pupils to demonstrate them, but what might change if pupils were genuinely involved in shaping their school culture?

  • What would they identify as the most important characteristics of a community where everyone belongs?
  • How might they define respect, inclusion, fairness or kindness?
  • What traditions would they want to retain, reconsider or introduce?
  • How might they create opportunities for pupils who currently feel disconnected?

Pupil councils, student leadership teams and consultation activities can provide valuable opportunities for participation. However, genuine agency requires more than being asked for an opinion – it requires pupils to see how their contributions influence decisions and lead to meaningful change.

We must also consider whose voices are heard – if the same pupils are consistently selected to represent their peers, we risk reinforcing existing hierarchies rather than broadening participation. A school community becomes stronger when its members are not simply expected to belong, but are empowered to shape what belonging means.

Staff Identity and Collective Responsibility

Although the DfE research focuses primarily on pupil belonging, its findings also reinforce the importance of staff wellbeing and belonging. A strong school identity cannot be sustained if staff feel disconnected from the values, leadership or culture of the organisation – staff need to understand the collective purpose of their work while feeling that their individual expertise, perspectives and contributions are recognised. This is particularly important in schools and trusts where teams may have different professional identities, experiences and priorities.

Collective identity should encourage collaboration rather than competition. It should create opportunities for colleagues to share knowledge, challenge assumptions and take responsibility for outcomes beyond their immediate classrooms or departments. For school trusts, this raises an additional challenge: How do we cultivate a shared trust identity while respecting the distinct histories, communities and cultures of individual schools?

A strong collective culture should not erase local identity. Instead, it should provide a shared framework of values, expectations and accountability that enables each school to flourish within its own context. This requires leaders to model the behaviours they expect from others. It also requires a willingness to move beyond individual priorities towards collective responsibility. A shared identity becomes meaningful when people recognise that the success, challenges and experiences of others are also their concern.

School Identity Is Experienced, Not Imposed

One of the most important messages emerging from the DfE research is that there is no universal blueprint for belonging. Schools need to understand their context, communities and individual pupils. This principle is equally important when cultivating a strong school identity as what creates connection in one school may not have the same impact in another:

  • Traditions that are meaningful to one community may feel unfamiliar or exclusionary to another.
  • Structures that work well in a small primary school may require adaptation within a large secondary school.

We therefore need to approach school identity with curiosity rather than assumption. This means listening to pupils, staff and families. It means recognising that different groups may experience the same school culture differently. It means being willing to examine established practices, even when they are longstanding or well-intentioned. And it means understanding that school identity is not static.

As communities evolve, our cultures must be able to respond. The strongest school identities are not necessarily those with the longest traditions or the clearest slogans. They are those where people experience a genuine sense of connection, recognition and shared responsibility.

Things to Consider This Week

As we reflect on the identity and culture of our school communities, we invite you to consider three questions.

  1. What unites us?

What are the values, experiences and shared commitments that create a sense of collective identity within our school? How consistently are these experienced by pupils, staff and families?

  1. Who might feel disconnected?

Which pupils or staff may struggle to see themselves reflected in our school identity? Are there traditions, expectations or structures that inadvertently create barriers to participation or belonging?

  1. How can we strengthen collective ownership?

What is one intentional action we could take this week to enable pupils or staff to contribute more meaningfully to shaping our school culture?

Perhaps:

  • it is revisiting our school values with pupils and exploring what they mean in practice;
  • it is reviewing participation in clubs, house activities or leadership opportunities;
  • it is inviting feedback from pupils who may feel less connected to school;
  • it is creating opportunities for staff across different teams or schools to collaborate;
  • it is questioning a longstanding tradition to ensure it remains inclusive and relevant.

The important thing is to recognise that a strong school identity is not something we simply communicate – it is something we collectively create, experience and sustain.

Final Reflections

A strong school identity can provide pupils and staff with a powerful sense of connection, purpose and pride. It can also strengthen relationships, encourage participation and create a shared commitment to the success and wellbeing of the whole community, but collective identity must never come at the expense of individual identity. We need to create school cultures where shared values provide direction without demanding conformity and where traditions strengthen connection without excluding difference.

Continue the Conversation

This is Part 4 of The Belonging Effect’s seven-week series, Belonging in Practice, exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s School Belonging Case Studies Research.

Next Monday, we will explore Every Child Matters: Individualising Belonging, considering how schools can recognise individual strengths, understand different needs and remove barriers to participation and success.

At The Belonging Effect, we support schools and organisations to move beyond good intentions and create cultures where belonging can be experienced, strengthened and measured.

Shaping Intention into Impact.

References and Further Reading

Department for Education (2026). School Belonging Case Studies Research. Research conducted by Ipsos in partnership with TONIC, Professor Kathryn Riley and the Anna Freud Centre.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/school-belonging-case-studies-research

The Belonging Effect: www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk

Privacy Preference Center