Belonging Effect Favicon

Written by Belonging Effect

Belonging Effect is committed to shaping intention into impact and supporting people with their Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, & Belonging strategy and training needs.

Belonging in Practice | Part 5 of 7

Equality gives everyone the same opportunities. Equity recognises that individuals may need different support to access those opportunities. Belonging requires us to understand the difference.

Over the past four weeks, we have been exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s (DfE) recently published School Belonging Case Studies Research. We have considered the importance of relationships, trust and psychological safety, celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination, and cultivating a strong school identity without compromising individuality.

This week, we turn our attention to another important area of practice identified in the research: individualised approaches to belonging. The research highlights how schools use their knowledge of individual pupils, alongside data, observation and relationships, to understand their strengths, identify barriers and provide tailored support.

This is an important reminder that while belonging is cultivated collectively, it is experienced individually. Two pupils can attend the same school, sit in the same classroom, experience the same teaching and follow the same expectations, yet have very different experiences of belonging.Treating everyone the same does not necessarily mean treating everyone fairly.

So how do we create school cultures where every child is recognised, understood, supported and empowered to flourish?

Knowing the Child Behind the Data

One of the five dimensions of belonging identified in the DfE research is individual recognition – this involves genuinely knowing pupils as individuals, recognising their strengths, understanding their needs and ensuring they feel safe to be themselves – schools hold significant amounts of information about their pupils.

We monitor attendance, attainment, behaviour, progress, additional needs, safeguarding concerns and a range of other indicators. These data provide valuable insights and can help us identify patterns, allocate resources and intervene when pupils require additional support, but data only tells part of the story:

  • An attendance percentage does not necessarily explain why a pupil is struggling to attend school.
  • A behaviour record does not reveal the full context of a child’s response to a particular situation.
  • An attainment grade does not capture their creativity, resilience, curiosity or potential.
  • A SEND diagnosis does not define the entirety of a child’s identity or experience.

We need to combine quantitative information with qualitative understanding. This requires relationships, observation, curiosity and meaningful conversations with pupils and their families. It also requires us to question our assumptions:

Do we know our pupils, or do we know the labels, categories and data associated with them?

Understanding the child behind the data enables us to move from responding to presenting difficulties towards recognising underlying needs, strengths and experiences.

Equality, Equity and the Difference Between Fairness and Sameness

Schools frequently describe their commitment to treating all pupils fairly, but fairness does not always mean providing everyone with exactly the same opportunities, resources or support.

Consider two pupils who are expected to participate in the same learning activity:

  • One may require additional processing time.
  • Another may need a quieter environment, an adapted resource or an alternative way to demonstrate their understanding.

Providing identical conditions does not necessarily create equitable opportunities to succeed.

Equity requires us to recognise that pupils begin from different starting points and may encounter different barriers. This does not mean lowering expectations – it means considering what support is necessary to enable pupils to meet ambitious expectations.

The DfE research reinforces the importance of maintaining high expectations alongside individualised support. This is particularly important because our assumptions about pupils’ capabilities can influence the opportunities we offer them. If we consistently underestimate a child’s potential because of their background, identity, disability or circumstances, we risk creating the very barriers we claim to be removing. Equally, if we insist that every child must demonstrate their capabilities in exactly the same way, we may inadvertently privilege some learners while disadvantaging others.

Equity is not about expecting less. It is about understanding what is needed to enable everyone to achieve more.

Inclusion Is About the Whole Child

Individualised approaches are often discussed primarily in relation to Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND). This is understandable as identifying needs, making reasonable adjustments and providing appropriate support are essential responsibilities for schools. However, individualising belonging requires us to consider more than SEND.

A child’s experience of school may also be shaped by their race, ethnicity, religion, gender, socioeconomic circumstances, family structure, language, disability, neurodivergence or experiences beyond the school gates. These identities and experiences may intersect in ways that create additional barriers or influence how support is accessed and experienced.

For example:

  • A neurodivergent pupil may experience sensory barriers that affect their ability to participate in particular school environments.
  • A pupil experiencing financial hardship may be unable to access enrichment opportunities that strengthen friendships and connection.
  • A child who is learning English as an additional language may need support to participate confidently while having considerable knowledge and skills in other languages.
  • A pupil experiencing racism or other forms of discrimination may feel unsafe or disconnected, despite receiving appropriate academic support.
  • A young carer may experience pressures outside school that affect their attendance, wellbeing and engagement.

These examples remind us that inclusion cannot be understood through one characteristic or category alone. Nor should we assume that pupils who share a particular identity will necessarily have the same experiences or needs.

Children do not arrive at school as a collection of separate characteristics. They arrive as whole people. So our approaches to inclusion must reflect this complexity.

Removing Barriers Rather Than Fixing Children

One of the most important questions we can ask when considering individualised approaches is where we locate the problem. When a pupil struggles to participate, engage or succeed, do we automatically assume that something needs to change about the child? Or do we also examine the environment, expectations, relationships and systems around them? 

This distinction is fundamental:

  • A pupil who struggles to concentrate in a noisy classroom may benefit from individual support, but we should also consider whether the learning environment can be adapted.
  • A child who repeatedly receives behaviour sanctions may need targeted intervention. But we should also examine whether expectations are clear, responses are equitable and underlying needs are understood.
  • A pupil who does not participate in extracurricular activities may appear disengaged. But we should explore whether financial, cultural, accessibility or social barriers are limiting their opportunities.

Individualised support is important, but it should not become a substitute for addressing systemic barriers. Otherwise, we risk asking children to adapt to environments that were not designed with their needs or experiences in mind.

Sometimes the most inclusive intervention is not changing the child. It is changing the conditions around them. This requires us to move beyond a deficit-based understanding of difference. Rather than asking only what a pupil cannot do, we should consider what they can do, what strengths they bring and what changes would enable them to participate more fully.

High Expectations, Appropriate Support and Pupil Agency

The DfE research highlights the reciprocal relationship between belonging, attendance and attainment. Leaders, staff and pupils described how feeling connected to school can encourage attendance and engagement, while positive learning experiences can strengthen belonging.

Importantly, the research also recognises that maintaining high expectations can communicate care and belief in pupils’ capabilities. However, high expectations must be accompanied by appropriate support.

We cannot simply tell pupils that we believe in them while failing to address the barriers that prevent them from succeeding. Nor should individualised approaches become something that is done to pupils without their involvement.

Pupil voice and agency are essential:

  • Do pupils understand the support being offered?
  • Have they been involved in identifying what works for them?
  • Are they able to express when an adjustment is unhelpful or makes them feel different from their peers?
  • Do they have opportunities to recognise their strengths, articulate their needs and influence decisions about their learning?

For some pupils, this may involve structured conversations or written feedback. For others, it may require visual communication, observation, trusted adults or alternative methods of participation. The important principle is that pupils should be active participants in shaping their experiences wherever possible – individualising belonging should strengthen agency, not create dependency.

The Importance of Families and Professional Collaboration

Understanding individual pupils requires us to recognise the expertise of those who know them well – families can provide invaluable insights into children’s strengths, interests, communication preferences, cultural identities and experiences beyond school.

Teachers, teaching assistants, pastoral staff, SENDCos and other professionals may also hold different pieces of the picture. However, these perspectives are not always brought together effectively:

  • Information may remain within individual teams.
  • Families may find themselves repeatedly explaining their child’s needs.
  • Pupils may experience inconsistent approaches across classrooms or transitions.
  • And well-intentioned interventions may become fragmented rather than coordinated.

A genuinely individualised approach requires collaboration and a joined up approach:

  • It involves listening to families without making assumptions about their circumstances or capabilities.
  • It involves sharing relevant information appropriately and ensuring that support is understood across the school.
  • It also involves reviewing whether interventions are having the intended impact.

Importantly, families should not have to become persistent advocates simply to secure support that their children need. Partnership should be built on mutual respect, shared understanding and collective responsibility.

From Individual Support to Inclusive Systems

There is an important balance to strike between responding to individual needs and creating environments that are inclusive by design. Schools cannot anticipate every circumstance or remove every barrier through universal approaches alone – individualised support will always be necessary, but we should also consider what repeated patterns tell us about our systems:

  • If several pupils struggle with the same transition, perhaps the transition process needs reviewing.
  • If particular groups are disproportionately represented in behaviour sanctions or exclusions, perhaps we need to interrogate our policies and practices.
  • If pupils with additional needs consistently miss enrichment opportunities, perhaps accessibility needs to be considered at the planning stage.
  • If families from particular communities rarely participate in school events, perhaps we need to reconsider how, when and where we engage with them.

Data can help us identify these patterns, but meaningful change requires us to understand the experiences behind them. This is where individualised approaches connect with whole-school leadership and accountability – we need to move beyond asking whether support is available and consider whether our systems are enabling everyone to participate, contribute and flourish. 

An inclusive school does not simply become better at supporting pupils who encounter barriers. It becomes more intentional about preventing unnecessary barriers from arising.

Things to Consider This Week

As we reflect on how individual pupils experience belonging within our school communities, we invite you to consider three questions.

  1. How well do we know our pupils?

Beyond attendance, attainment and behaviour data, what do we understand about their identities, strengths, experiences, aspirations and barriers to belonging? Whose stories might we not yet have heard?

  1. Where are the barriers?

When pupils struggle to participate, engage or succeed, do we focus primarily on changing their behaviour or providing individual interventions? How often do we examine the environments, expectations and systems that may be contributing to their experiences?

  1. What could we change this week?

What is one intentional action we could take to remove a barrier, strengthen pupil agency or create a more equitable experience of belonging?

Perhaps:

  • it is having a conversation with a pupil whose needs or experiences we do not fully understand;
  • it is reviewing an intervention with the pupil and their family;
  • it is examining participation data to identify who may be missing out;
  • it is adapting a classroom routine or learning environment;
  • it is questioning an assumption about what a particular pupil can achieve.

Small, intentional changes can make a significant difference to individual experiences, but we must also be willing to examine the wider systems that shape those experiences.

Final Reflections

Every child deserves to be recognised, respected and valued as an individual, but individualising belonging is not simply about creating different interventions for different pupils:

  • It is about understanding the whole child, recognising their strengths, listening to their experiences and removing the barriers that prevent them from participating fully.
  • It requires us to maintain high expectations while providing equitable opportunities to succeed.
  • It requires us to balance individual support with collective responsibility.
  • And it requires us to examine whether our school cultures, systems and expectations are genuinely inclusive or whether some pupils are continually expected to adapt to environments that do not meet their needs.

The DfE research reminds us that belonging is cultivated through intentional, contextual and sustained practice. There is no universal blueprint, but there is a shared responsibility to understand how our school communities are experienced and to respond to what we discover.

Because every child matters, every experience matters and belonging should never depend on a child’s ability to overcome barriers that we have the power to remove.

Continue the Conversation

This is Part 5 of The Belonging Effect’s seven-week series, Belonging in Practice, exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s School Belonging Case Studies Research.

Next Monday, we will explore Belonging Beyond the School Gates, considering how relationships with families, communities and wider partnerships can strengthen belonging and create opportunities for children and young people to flourish.

At The Belonging Effect, we support schools and organisations to move beyond good intentions and create cultures where belonging can be experienced, strengthened and measured.

Shaping Intention into Impact.

References and Further Reading

Department for Education (2026). School Belonging Case Studies Research. Research conducted by Ipsos in partnership with TONIC, Professor Kathryn Riley and the Anna Freud Centre.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/school-belonging-case-studies-research

The Belonging Effect: www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk

Privacy Preference Center