Written by Belonging Effect
Belonging Effect is committed to shaping intention into impact and supporting people with their Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, & Belonging strategy and training needs.
Belonging in Practice | Part 3 of 7
Belonging is not about fitting in. It is about being recognised, respected and valued for who we are.
Over the past two weeks, we have been exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s (DfE) recently published School Belonging Case Studies Research. We began by considering what belonging means in practice, before examining the importance of relationships, trust, psychological safety and connection.
This week, we turn our attention to the third area of practice identified in the research: celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination.
The research highlights the importance of meaningfully embedding pupils’ cultures and identities throughout the curriculum and wider school life, alongside a compassionate, zero-tolerance approach to discrimination. This is a welcome recognition that belonging cannot be cultivated without addressing issues of identity, representation, equity and inclusion. But it also raises some important questions:
- What does it really mean to celebrate diversity?
- How do we move beyond representation towards meaningful inclusion?
- And how do we ensure that our commitment to challenging discrimination is experienced consistently across our school communities?
Belonging Is Not the Same as Fitting In
One of the most important distinctions we can make when discussing belonging is the difference between belonging and fitting in:
- Fitting in often requires individuals to adapt themselves to the expectations, behaviours and norms of the dominant culture.
- Belonging, however, should enable individuals to participate fully without compromising their identities.
This distinction is particularly important in schools, where children and young people are developing their understanding of themselves, their relationships and their place in the world.
When pupils feel that aspects of their identity need to be hidden, minimised or changed to gain acceptance, we must question whether they are genuinely experiencing belonging. This may relate to their race, ethnicity, religion, gender, sexuality, disability, neurodivergence, socioeconomic background or family circumstances. And, crucially, these identities do not exist in isolation.
We cannot claim to cultivate belonging while expecting individuals to leave aspects of themselves at the school gates. Creating inclusive school cultures requires us to recognise and value difference, while challenging the assumptions, stereotypes and inequalities that can prevent individuals from participating fully.
Celebrating Diversity: Beyond the Calendar
Many schools work hard to celebrate diversity – they organise cultural events, recognise religious festivals, celebrate awareness months and create displays that reflect the richness of their communities.
These activities can provide valuable opportunities for learning, connection and celebration. However, we must also consider whether diversity is meaningfully embedded throughout the school year or confined to particular events and occasions:
- Does our curriculum reflect diverse histories, cultures, identities and contributions?
- Are pupils exposed to a range of authors, artists, scientists, historians, leaders and role models?
- Do we challenge stereotypes and dominant narratives, or inadvertently reinforce them?
- Are different family structures, languages, beliefs and lived experiences recognised as part of everyday school life?
- And whose stories remain absent?
A diverse curriculum is not simply about adding more representation. It is about examining whose knowledge is valued, whose perspectives are centred and whose contributions are recognised. For example, celebrating Black History Month is important, but Black history should not be confined to October. Recognising International Women’s Day has value, but women’s achievements and experiences should be embedded throughout the curriculum. Similarly, acknowledging religious festivals can strengthen understanding, but genuine religious inclusion also requires us to consider how school routines, expectations and practices accommodate different beliefs.
Celebrating diversity should not be an occasional activity. It should be an everyday experience.
From Representation to Inclusion
Representation matters – seeing people who share aspects of our identities reflected in the curriculum, school environment and wider community can strengthen our sense of recognition and belonging, but representation alone does not guarantee inclusion:
- A pupil may see their culture celebrated in an assembly while experiencing discriminatory language in the playground.
- A school may display inclusive values while some families feel excluded from decision-making.
- A member of staff may see diversity reflected in recruitment materials while experiencing barriers to professional development or progression.
This is where we need to move beyond visibility and consider lived experience:
- Are pupils able to participate meaningfully?
- Are their perspectives listened to and acted upon?
- Do they experience fairness in how expectations, opportunities, rewards and sanctions are applied?
- Are staff from different backgrounds equally recognised, supported and empowered?
- Do families experience genuine partnership, or are some voices heard more readily than others?
Representation is about being visible. Inclusion is about being valued, involved and empowered.
Both are essential, but neither should be mistaken for the other.
Challenging Discrimination: Compassion and Accountability
The DfE research highlights the importance of a compassionate, zero-tolerance approach to discrimination. This combination deserves careful consideration.
Schools have a responsibility to challenge discriminatory language, attitudes and behaviours, whether these relate to racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia, transphobia, religious discrimination or other forms of prejudice. However, a commitment to zero tolerance must be more than a statement in a policy. It must be reflected in how schools prevent discrimination, respond when incidents occur, support those who experience harm and hold individuals accountable.
There is also an important distinction between challenging discriminatory behaviour and labelling children as inherently discriminatory. Children and young people are developing their understanding of identity, difference, power and relationships. They may repeat language they have heard without fully understanding its meaning or impact. This does not mean that discriminatory behaviour should be excused or minimised. It means that our responses should combine clear boundaries, education, accountability and appropriate support.
We need to consider:
- How do we respond when discriminatory language or behaviour occurs?
- Do pupils and staff feel safe to report concerns?
- Are incidents recorded, monitored and addressed consistently?
- Do we recognise patterns of discrimination, rather than treating every incident as isolated?
- Are those who experience discrimination listened to, supported and protected?
- Do our responses enable learning and change without minimising the harm caused?
Compassion does not mean avoiding difficult conversations or consequences. Equally, accountability should not mean abandoning our commitment to education, dignity and growth.
We can challenge behaviour without dehumanising individuals. We can demonstrate compassion without compromising accountability.
Understanding Intersectionality
An important consideration when cultivating belonging is recognising that identities and experiences intersect. Kimberlé Crenshaw’s concept of intersectionality provides a valuable framework for understanding how different forms of inequality and discrimination can overlap:
- A Black girl may experience school differently from a Black boy.
- A neurodivergent pupil from a disadvantaged socioeconomic background may encounter barriers that are not fully understood through a SEND lens alone.
- A Muslim pupil with a disability may experience challenges related to religion, accessibility and representation.
These experiences cannot always be understood by considering individual characteristics separately. Yet schools frequently organise their approaches to inclusion around distinct categories. We may have separate strategies for SEND, disadvantage, racial equity, gender equality and other aspects of inclusion.
While targeted approaches can be important, we must also consider how these priorities intersect as children do not experience their identities in separate compartments. Neither should our approaches to inclusion take a single-issue approach.
An intersectional approach requires us to be curious about individual experiences, interrogate patterns within our data and listen carefully to those whose perspectives may challenge our assumptions. It also requires us to recognise that pupils who share an identity will not necessarily share the same experiences.
Our responsibility is not to make assumptions about what individuals need because of who they are, but instead to understand their experiences and respond appropriately.
Pupil Voice: Listening, Learning and Acting
One of the six practice themes identified in the DfE research is pupil voice and agency. Although we are focusing on diversity and discrimination this week, pupil voice is integral to understanding whether our inclusive intentions are becoming lived experiences.
Schools cannot determine how inclusive they are simply by reviewing their policies, curriculum plans or displays. We need to ask the people experiencing our cultures:
- Do pupils feel safe to be themselves?
- Do they see their identities and experiences reflected in school life?
- Do they feel respected by their peers and the adults around them?
- Do they believe discrimination will be challenged consistently?
- And, perhaps most importantly, do they believe that speaking up will lead to meaningful change?
However, we also need to consider whose voices are represented in our feedback mechanisms:
- Are we listening primarily to confident, articulate pupils who already feel connected to school?
- How do we hear from pupils who are disengaged, marginalised or reluctant to speak?
- What opportunities do we create for anonymous feedback, smaller conversations and alternative forms of participation?
- And what happens after pupils share their experiences?
Pupil voice without meaningful influence risks becoming consultation without change. Listening is important. Acting on what we hear is what demonstrates that people’s experiences matter.
Creating a Culture of Collective Responsibility
Celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination cannot be the responsibility of a single member of staff, department or working group. It requires collective ownership:
- School leaders have a responsibility to establish clear expectations, allocate resources, provide professional learning and ensure that inclusive values are reflected in policies and decision-making.
- Teachers and support staff have a responsibility to examine their curriculum, language, assumptions and everyday interactions.
- Governors and trustees have a responsibility to provide strategic oversight and hold leaders accountable for the experiences of their communities.
- Pupils also have an important role in shaping inclusive cultures through their relationships, behaviours and willingness to challenge prejudice.
But responsibility must be accompanied by support – we cannot assume that everyone has the knowledge, confidence or competence to recognise and respond effectively to discrimination. Professional learning needs to move beyond awareness towards developing the skills required for courageous conversations, inclusive decision-making and appropriate intervention.
We also need to create environments where adults can acknowledge gaps in their understanding, reflect on mistakes and continue learning – inclusive cultures are not created by people who never get things wrong. They are created by people who are prepared to recognise, challenge and change what is wrong.
Things to Consider This Week
As we reflect on how diversity is celebrated and discrimination is challenged within our school communities, we invite you to consider three questions.
- Who is represented?
Whose identities, histories, cultures and experiences are reflected in our curriculum, school environment and wider community? Whose stories might be missing, marginalised or misrepresented?
- Who experiences inclusion differently?
What do our pupils, staff and families tell us about their experiences of discrimination, fairness and belonging? Are we listening to those whose experiences may challenge our assumptions?
- What are we prepared to change?
What is one intentional action we could take this week to strengthen representation, challenge discrimination or remove a barrier to inclusion?
- Perhaps it is reviewing a curriculum resource.
- Perhaps it is examining patterns within behaviour or exclusion data.
- Perhaps it is creating a safer opportunity for pupils to share their experiences.
- Or perhaps it is challenging language or behaviour that has become normalised within our school community.
The important thing is that our commitment to diversity and inclusion is demonstrated through our actions, not simply our intentions.
Final Reflections
Celebrating diversity and challenging discrimination are interconnected responsibilities. We cannot meaningfully celebrate difference while allowing prejudice, discrimination or exclusion to go unchallenged. Equally, we cannot create inclusive cultures solely by responding to incidents of discrimination.
We must also intentionally cultivate environments where diverse identities, experiences and contributions are recognised, respected and valued. This requires more than policies, displays, assemblies or awareness campaigns. It requires us to examine the cultures we create, the behaviours we tolerate, the voices we prioritise and the barriers we may inadvertently sustain. It requires curiosity, courage, compassion and accountability. And it requires us to recognise that belonging is not achieved by expecting everyone to become the same.
Belonging is cultivated when we create the conditions for everyone to be themselves, contribute meaningfully and experience dignity, equity and respect.
Continue the Conversation
This is Part 3 of The Belonging Effect’s seven-week series, Belonging in Practice, exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s School Belonging Case Studies Research.
Next Monday, we will explore Cultivating a Strong School Identity, considering how shared values, collective purpose and school communities can strengthen belonging without compromising individuality.
At The Belonging Effect, we support schools and organisations to move beyond good intentions and create cultures where belonging can be experienced, strengthened and measured.
Shaping Intention into Impact.
References and Further Reading
Department for Education (2026). School Belonging Case Studies Research. Research conducted by Ipsos in partnership with TONIC, Professor Kathryn Riley and the Anna Freud Centre.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/school-belonging-case-studies-research
Crenshaw, K. (1989). Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum.
The Belonging Effect: www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk
