Belonging Effect Favicon

Written by Belonging Effect

Belonging Effect is committed to shaping intention into impact and supporting people with their Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, & Belonging strategy and training needs.

Belonging in Practice | Part 2 of 7

Relationships create connection. Trust creates safety. But belonging requires us to turn both into consistent, inclusive practice.

Last week, we launched our seven-part series, Belonging in Practice, exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s (DfE) recently published School Belonging Case Studies Research. We began by considering the importance of moving beyond good intentions to create school cultures where belonging is genuinely experienced by everyone.

This week, we turn our attention to the first of the six areas of practice identified in the research: relational practices. The research reinforces something that many educators instinctively understand. Relationships matter. But what does it mean to intentionally cultivate relationships that strengthen belonging? And how do we ensure that these relationships are experienced consistently and equitably across our school communities?

Relationships Are the Foundation, Not the Finishing Line

The DfE research identifies positive relationships as one of five interconnected dimensions of belonging. It also highlights relational practices as a central feature of the schools studied.

Across these schools, relationships were not simply the responsibility of pastoral teams or individual members of staff. They were cultivated throughout the school community, between leaders and staff, staff and pupils, pupils and their peers, and schools and families.

This is an important distinction – relationships are not an additional responsibility alongside teaching, learning, leadership and safeguarding. They are integral to how we approach all of these responsibilities.

Every interaction communicates something about whether we are seen, heard, respected and valued:

  • A warm welcome at the classroom door.
  • A colleague who notices when someone is struggling.
  • A teacher who takes the time to understand why a pupil’s behaviour has changed.
  • A leader who listens without immediately becoming defensive.
  • A parent who feels welcomed into a conversation rather than judged by it.

These interactions may appear small, but collectively they shape how people experience their school community. However, we should not confuse positive relationships with belonging itself.

A school can have warm, friendly relationships while some pupils and staff continue to experience exclusion, discrimination or marginalisation. Being liked is not the same as being included. Being welcomed is not necessarily the same as belonging. The challenge is to ensure that positive relationships create the conditions for everyone to participate, contribute and flourish.

From Psychological Safety to Relational Safety

One of the most important conditions for cultivating belonging is psychological safety. Amy Edmondson’s work on psychological safety has helped us understand the importance of creating environments where people feel able to speak up, ask questions, acknowledge mistakes and express concerns without fear of humiliation or interpersonal punishment.

In schools, this has implications for both pupils and adults:

  • Can a pupil admit that they do not understand something without fearing embarrassment?
  • Can a teacher ask for support without worrying that their competence will be questioned?
  • Can a teaching assistant challenge a decision that they believe may disadvantage a child?
  • Can a middle leader raise concerns with senior colleagues without fearing negative consequences?

These questions reveal something important about the relationship between power, trust and belonging. Psychological safety is not simply about creating comfortable environments. It is about ensuring that people feel sufficiently safe to be honest, vulnerable and courageous.

Equally, we also need to consider relational safety. Relational safety is cultivated through the consistency, reliability and quality of our interactions with others. It develops when people experience care, respect, appropriate boundaries and trust over time:

  • A pupil may feel comfortable speaking to one trusted teacher but not another.
  • A colleague may feel psychologically safe within their immediate team but not in meetings with senior leaders.
  • A parent may trust their child’s class teacher while feeling disconnected from the wider school.

Belonging cannot depend solely on which classroom, colleague or leader someone encounters. We need to consider how psychological and relational safety are cultivated across the whole school, rather than relying on isolated pockets of positive practice.

High Expectations and High Support

An encouraging finding from the DfE research is the recognition that belonging and high expectations are not competing priorities. Indeed, leaders, staff and pupils described high expectations as an expression of care and belief in pupils’ capabilities. This resonates with the relationship between challenge and support.

When we genuinely believe in someone’s potential, we do not necessarily lower our expectations. We provide the encouragement, guidance, resources and opportunities they need to succeed. However, high expectations without relational safety can feel threatening.

Equally, positive relationships without any appropriate challenge may create comfort without enabling growth.

The challenge for educators and leaders is to cultivate cultures where people feel both supported and appropriately challenged:

  • Where mistakes become opportunities for learning rather than sources of shame.
  • Where accountability is accompanied by compassion.
  • Where difficult conversations can take place without damaging dignity.
  • Where expectations are applied equitably, while recognising that individuals may require different forms of support to meet them.

Care and challenge are not opposites. At their best, they reinforce one another.

Repairing Relationships When Things Go Wrong

No school community is free from conflict, disagreement or mistakes. Relationships are complex – people misunderstand one another, make assumptions, experience frustration and sometimes cause harm.

The strength of a relational culture is not demonstrated by the absence of conflict. Instead, it is demonstrated by how we respond when relationships become strained:

  • Do we seek to understand before making judgements?
  • Do we create opportunities for people to explain their experiences?
  • Are we willing to acknowledge mistakes and apologise?

Restorative approaches can provide opportunities to rebuild trust and strengthen relationships, particularly when they are embedded within a wider culture of care, fairness and accountability. However, repairing relationships does not mean avoiding consequences or expecting those who have experienced harm to forgive or reconcile before they are ready – it requires us to acknowledge harm, uphold boundaries and take responsibility for change.

This is particularly important when addressing discrimination, bullying or exclusion. We cannot cultivate belonging by asking those who have experienced harm to accommodate the discomfort of others. Relational practice must be compassionate, but it must also be courageous.

Staff Belonging: We Cannot Give What We Do Not Experience

One of the strongest messages emerging from the DfE research is the importance of prioritising staff wellbeing and belonging. This deserves particular attention.

We frequently discuss the responsibility of educators to create safe, supportive and inclusive environments for pupils. But we also need to consider whether the adults working in our schools experience these conditions themselves:

  • Do staff feel recognised and valued?
  • Are their professional contributions respected?
  • Can they express different perspectives without being labelled difficult?
  • Do they experience fairness, flexibility and compassion?
  • Are they supported when facing challenges, or expected simply to cope?

School leaders play a significant role in shaping these experiences. The way leaders communicate, respond to mistakes, distribute responsibilities, manage conflict and recognise contributions influences the culture experienced by staff. And that culture inevitably shapes the relationships adults build with pupils.

If we want educators to demonstrate empathy, patience, curiosity and compassion, we must consider the organisational conditions that enable them to do so. Staff belonging cannot be reduced to wellbeing activities, occasional gestures of appreciation or social events. It requires sustained attention to workload, professional trust, equity, recognition, development and the quality of relationships across the organisation. We cannot expect staff to consistently cultivate a culture of belonging for pupils if they do not experience belonging themselves.

Moving from Individual Relationships to Collective Responsibility

The DfE research highlights that belonging is everyone’s responsibility. This means moving beyond reliance on individual staff members who are particularly skilled at building relationships.

Every school has those colleagues:

  • The teacher who seems able to connect with the most disengaged pupils.
  • The pastoral leader who knows every family.
  • The teaching assistant who notices when something is wrong.
  • The colleague everyone approaches when they need support.

These individuals make an invaluable contribution to school culture. However, belonging should not depend on their presence as what happens when they leave, change roles or are absent? How do we thus ensure that their approaches are understood, shared and embedded across the school?

This requires intentional leadership. It means investing in professional learning, creating opportunities for collaboration, modelling inclusive behaviours and ensuring that policies and systems reinforce relational practice.

It also requires us to examine inconsistencies:

  • Are some pupils more likely than others to receive compassion, patience or second chances?
  • Do all staff experience the same opportunities to contribute and be heard?
  • Are relationships with families shaped by genuine partnership or by assumptions about their circumstances, identities and experiences?

These are not always comfortable questions. But they are necessary if we want to move from isolated examples of good practice to a genuinely inclusive school culture.

Things to Consider This Week

As you reflect on the relationships within your school community, we invite you to consider three questions.

  1. Who feels safe?

How do we know that pupils and staff feel psychologically and relationally safe? Are there differences between teams, classrooms or groups that we need to understand?

  1. How do we respond when relationships are challenged?

Do our approaches to conflict, mistakes and difficult conversations strengthen trust and accountability, or inadvertently create fear, silence and disengagement?

  1. What could we do differently?

What is one intentional action we could take this week to strengthen a relationship, repair trust or create greater connection within our school community?

Perhaps:

  • it is checking in with someone whose voice has been missing;
  • it is inviting honest feedback from colleagues;
  • it is reconsidering how we respond when a pupil makes a mistake;
  • it is having a courageous conversation that we have been avoiding.

The important thing is not simply identifying what needs to change – it is being prepared to act.

Final Reflections

Relationships are at the heart of school life. They influence how we learn, lead, collaborate, communicate and experience our communities. But cultivating belonging requires us to look beyond the existence of positive relationships and consider their quality, consistency and inclusivity:

  • Who experiences trust?
  • Who feels safe?
  • Who is recognised, respected and valued?
  • And who may still be standing on the margins of our school community, despite our best intentions?

As the DfE research reminds us, belonging is cultivated through intentional, collective and sustained practice. It is not the responsibility of one individual, team or department. It is the responsibility of us all, because belonging begins with relationships, but it is sustained through the trust, safety and accountability we create together.

Continue the Conversation

This is Part 2 of The Belonging Effect’s seven-week series, Belonging in Practice, exploring the findings from the Department for Education’s School Belonging Case Studies Research.

Next Monday, we will explore Celebrating Diversity and Challenging Discrimination, considering how schools can ensure that every pupil’s identity, culture and lived experience are recognised, respected and valued.

At The Belonging Effect, we support schools and organisations to move beyond good intentions and create cultures where belonging can be experienced, strengthened and measured.

Shaping Intention into Impact.

References and Further Reading

Department for Education (2026). School Belonging Case Studies Research. Research conducted by Ipsos in partnership with TONIC, Professor Kathryn Riley and the Anna Freud Centre.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/school-belonging-case-studies-research

Edmondson, A. (2019). The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation, and Growth. Wiley.

The Belonging Effect: www.thebelongingeffect.co.uk

Privacy Preference Center